Clarification on Emily Proudfoot's Response to Our Petition

Dear Signers and Supporters,
Eugene's Landscape Architect, Emily Proudfoot has been responsible for withdrawing park benches, garbage cans, and even irrigation from Scobert Park. The City has ignored clear results from the its own survey that showed residents wanted more trees and vegetation NOT a concrete plaza.
Ms. Proudfoot and Cameron McCarthy presented two drawings - both of them using a considerable amount of concrete paving over the hottest part of the park. There were no other alternatives.
As you can see in the graphic I uploaded from Survey #2, the paved plaza ranked dead last for one of the options as something residents wanted in Scobert. For the second option, a concrete plaza was second to last among residents' wants. Unsurprisingly, increased greenery and trees was consistently one of the top desires among residents for what they wanted in the park. The City/Cameron McCarthy completely ignored these survey results and pressed forward with the design anyway.
Neighbors were alarmed by the amount of concrete that was being pushed through the process and canvassed Whiteaker, knocking on doors and leaving flyers for a meeting. Thirty neighbors showed up, hammered out a design (executed by a Whiteaker artist) and presented it next to the Cameron McCarthy rendering at the City's September 2023 meeting. At that meeting Ms. Proudfoot approached the designer, indicated that she knew it was the original draft and asked to take it. The designer refused fearing it would simply be "lost" but instead furnished the City with a copy. The grassroots drawing was never entered into consideration for public comment.
The "Big Move": Full Enclosure of the Park and Misleading Renderings
At a Whiteaker Community Council meeting, Ms. Proudfoot announced a "big move" to fence and gate the entire park to gasps and anger from many residents. The enclosure of the entire park was never presented as a choice. Ms Proudfoot showed misleading computer renderings of the park which give the impression of a lot more greenery and shade than is actually present or even possible given the abundance of hardscape.
Sun From the North?
One computer drawing depicts shade from the street trees across much of the concrete plaza. The angle of the shadows would only be possible if the sun was shining on the trees from the north at noon instead of from the south where we all know it is. Either the landscape designers do not know the direction from which the sun shines, or the drawing is deliberately misleading to give the impression that the massive amount of hardscape will be shaded at some point. This is simply not true and we can furnish evidence of this, as we use the park regularly.
Old Growth?
Another City/Cameron McCarthy drawing (from the back of the park looking toward the street) shows a row of enormous 100+ year old trees across the street from the park. This image is a completely false representation of greenery on 4th Avenue at that location. The trees in City/Cameron McCarthy are those that I planted in 1995. They are not nearly as full and tall as the ones in the rendering. One of the trees presented is of a dying big leaf maple surrounded by asphalt that has been neglected by the business owner and has been dropping limbs for years.
What The City's Design Will Do
1. Breaking ground will cut the roots of the struggling maple street trees at the front of the park. There is no question that they will die.
2. The concrete plaza will raise the temperature of the block placing low income people and those who lack air conditioning in danger during heat waves. It will possibly cause the death of more trees in the park and on private property.
3. The fence and gates will not be "welcoming" but will negatively impact social cohesion and will be part of a process that ensures the death of Scobert, which the City seems to be pursuing just like in the case of the ironically-named Martin Luther King Jr. park.
What Does this Mean For Eugeneans?
What the City does to poor neighborhoods is a test case for other neighborhoods. Normalization of these kinds of measures - policing, neglect, withdrawal of services, and inequitable "solutions" affect everyone in the form of increased social costs. Those costs fall on everyone.
Please show up at Scobert Park on July 23rd at 5.30 pm and tell Ms. Proudfoot that concrete and gates are not acceptable. Whiteaker residents deserve better.
Yours,
sue