Petition updateProtect Penicuik Green Spaces: Reject Housing Sites R25, R26, and R27!

1,700 Signatures & Vital New Evidence: Shifting the Battle to Infrastructure and Education Capacity

Angie CairneyUnited Kingdom
Oct 10, 2026

First of all, a massive thank you to our community, our petition has officially passed 1,700 signatures! Your continued support keeps our campaign incredibly visible as the local development plan moves through the council's assessment phase.

While the public consultation window has closed, our team has been tracking the infrastructure and education reality on the ground. We have secured vital admissions that completely undermine the deliverability of housing sites R25, R26, and R27.

🚰 The Developer's Written Admission

On 8 October, the project team at Cala Homes admitted in writing to a local resident that critical underground "drainage works" and "design approvals" remain entirely unresolved with statutory authorities. They also confirmed that a crucial Road Safety Audit will not take place until late October, meaning they cannot provide a confirmed opening date for the unadopted Silurian Road corridor.

Laying final-phase road surfacing while deep underlying drainage systems remain legally unapproved next to a high-pressure, 120-year-old raw water aqueduct turns standard engineering order completely on its head.

🚰 Scottish Water’s Statutory Deadline Breach

On 9 October, Scottish Water officially missed its legal statutory deadline to release the critical hydraulic capacity logs and aqueduct engineering records our campaign requested under Freedom of Information mandates. They have formally apologised, citing the high complexity of the data, and we have upgraded our request into a statutory "Requirement for Review" to lock in a new deadline of 6 November. This means that while the developer is pushing ahead on the surface, the public utility operator has been unable to verify the underlying network safety parameters in time.

🎒 The Primary School Disclosures & Mauricewood Extension

Through a formal transparency request, the council's Asset Management department has been forced to disclose the exact internal financial metrics for our local school estate. The numbers are staggering. The council has officially admitted that our immediate primary schools are sitting on a combined structural maintenance backlog and deferred capital repair bill of over £5.5 million:

❌ Cornbank Primary School: Disclosed structural backlog of £4,081,820.
❌ Cuiken Primary School: Disclosed structural backlog of £1,445,162.
❌ Strathesk Primary School: Figures hidden behind a private Public-Private Partnership (PPP) contract.


This aligns with news across the town. Following immense pressure from parents, the council has finally lodged a planning application for a circa £4 million, six-classroom modular extension at Mauricewood Primary to address the severe capacity crunch. While it is brilliant news that these improvements are moving forward, the council's strategy relies heavily on future developer contributions to fund this new space, while remaining silent on the outstanding maintenance backlog of the existing, aging building fabric.

Our campaign team has officially launched a brand-new Environmental Information Regulation request on the public timeline, placing a strict statutory clock on the council to force them to hand over the exact internal condition surveys, repair logs, and outstanding deficit sheets for Mauricewood Primary School by 29 October 2026.

📝 The True Secondary Education Crisis: Penicuik High Capacity Failure

The primary school logjam leads directly into an even more severe, terminal bottleneck at the secondary level. A simple, back-of-the-napkin capacity check exposes how reckless the council's planning model truly is:

The Hard Structural Ceiling: The physical footprint of Penicuik High School is strictly capped at a maximum of 945 student places. Crucially, the ongoing £55.3 million investment is purely a structural refurbishment to fix the aging building fabric—it adds zero new capacity or extra desks.


The Current Baseline: The current baseline school roll sits at approximately 627 pupils, meaning the remaining structural cushion across the entire localised network is limited to just 318 desks.


The Premature Catchment Burden: Following the closure of Glencorse Primary, the council formally realigned the expanding Mauricewood Primary catchment stream directly into Penicuik High. This is already forcing a major, growing primary feeder track into the school long before the replacement Beeslack campus at Seafield Moor Road is completed in August 2029. Crucially, the Beeslack replacement is not designed or zoned to take Penicuik children; it serves an entirely separate catchment area, leaving Penicuik High completely on its own to absorb the realigned burden.


The Funding and Construction Delays: The replacement Beeslack campus has already been stuck in the planning and procurement works for years without a single brick being laid on-site. If a replacement campus for a completely separate catchment takes nearly a decade just to break ground, a desperately needed second high school or major capacity expansion for Penicuik children should be in the structural planning pipeline right now. Instead, it is completely absent from the council's infrastructure plan.


The MLDP2 Breaking Point: Under the council's statutory ratio of 0.2 pupils per house, the 438 units proposed for our greenfield ridge (Sites R25, R26, and R27) will add 88 secondary pupils. When combined with wider town allocations and hidden windfall additions—such as the un-mapped 46 affordable units at Site H58 Area F—this cumulative housing strain adds over 240 secondary pupils to the town.


When this massive developer load is placed on top of the already overloaded Mauricewood catchment stream, the school roll is projected to completely breach the 945 structural ceiling by 2029. Under National Planning Framework 4 Policy 18 (Infrastructure First), you cannot legally allocate massive greenfield expansions to connect into an educational network that is already facing imminent capacity insolvency.

Join our Facebook group for more updates: https://www.facebook.com/groups/1068950205672113/