A Plea for Justice: Part 4, "Jealous of Everyone", examines the relationship between Stacey Stites and Jimmy Fennell in the months, weeks and days leading up the murder. Contrary to trial testimony heard by jurors, recovered police reports and new witness statements indicate the Stites and Fennell were frequently fighting, Fennell was constantly jealous and threatening, and Stites was afraid Fennell would discover that she was being unfaithful. Additionally, new critical witnesses have recently come forward. These witnesses include a life insurance agent who says she heard Fennell threaten to kill Stites if he ever discovered her cheating, and a former Lee County Sheriff's deputy who heard Fennell, at Stites funeral, say to the victim's dead body that she "got what she deserved."