Petition updateBin Emmerdale's Prejudiced Storyline About Down's Syndrome

Please Help With Ofcom Complaints!

Rachel MewesEllington, ENG, United Kingdom
20 Nov 2020

Thank you for your support so far with the Emmerdale campaign. There isn’t much more we can do regarding complaint letters until the story airs, but we are able to complain about the trailer as that has been released. We have located a showing on Lorraine on 9th Nov, and have put together a letter of complaint below. 

The link to watch the Lorraine clip can be found here. https://bit.ly/3nEGEQf  Please give it a ‘thumbs down’ before submitting your complaint. 

Please support us in complaining to Ofcom. There is a deadline for complaints so please do this asap for yours to be considered. Instructions and copy below. Please feel free to tweak, amend and personalise, but it is already at max. wording so don’t add any extra words. Please can each individual in the family send a separate complaint, and invite friends and family to do the same. The number of complaints will make a difference here, so please take a few minutes to support us.

Visit: 

https://ofcomforms.secure.force.com/formentry/SitesFormCSLEStandardsComplaints 

Programme details

Title: Lorraine 

Date: 09.11.20

Time: 9am 

Channel ITV 

Your Complaint 

Subject

Lorraine is interviewing an actor from the soap Emmerdale about a forthcoming controversial storyline involving the termination of a pregnancy as the result of a pre-natal diagnosis of Down syndrome (DS). A trailer advertising the forthcoming plot is then shown, alongside an interview with the actor Charlotte Bellamy.  This trailer has also been sent out to all media companies and is being widely featured on multiple channels and platforms because of the public outcry. This programme clip can currently be viewed on YouTube  https://bit.ly/3nEGEQf .    


Description

I would like to complain about the Lorraine interview and the trailer for Emmerdale on the following grounds: 

The forthcoming storyline and trailer has caused a public outcry because it is outdated, ill-informed and discriminatory.  Thousands of people have been offended by the trailer and storyline, and many MPs are now raising this issue at Parliament and calling for the storyline to be dropped. There is a petition with over 23,000 signatures asking for the storyline to be changed and the story is being extensively covered in the national press.  The subsequent release of this clip acting as, in Emmerdale’s frothy words, a ‘sneak-peek’ of the plot is insensitive and inflammatory, with ratings being considered before the feelings of the DS community. 

Despite being fully aware of the pain and distress the forthcoming storyline is causing to families like mine, the Lorraine programme gave an uninterrupted platform to advertise the programme, and also showed the trailer knowing the upset this could cause individuals with Down syndrome and their families.  The programme producers are fully aware of the controversy surrounding the storyline but proceeded to show the clip highlighting the controversy and gave the warning that ‘you might find this clip upsetting.’  Indeed, my family did find this clip incredibly distressing. 

As a parent of a young person with Down syndrome I feel this clip and its storyline breaches Ofcom regulations.  Ofcom Harm and Offence guidelines state, ‘Discriminatory Treatments Relating to Disability: ‘If there is a use of stereotypes and caricatures of the discussion of difficult or controversial issues involving that community it may be seen as offensive, in that it is viewed as creating a false impression of that minority.’ We believe that Ofcom guidelines have been breached. This storyline would not have been permitted if the words Down syndrome were replaced with any other minority group involving race, disability, gender, or sexuality, and therefore this storyline is discriminatory.  

It is therefore also a breach of the Equality Act 2010 which states you, or anyone connected to you,  must not be discriminated against on the grounds of disability, gender, race, religion or sexual orientation.   

The storyline could easily have proceeded if the condition had been non-specific, and without specifically naming ‘Down syndrome’ without causing offense to many thousands of people with Down syndrome and their families. Indeed, the clip shows the medical professional first referring to ‘a type of chromosomal syndrome’. 

However, the story then takes a dark turn.  There is a look of horror on both actors’ faces as the ‘dreaded’ words Down syndrome are stuttered.  Even the room is dark and gloomy which sets a negative scene for what is to come next. There is clear and recognised guidance for practitioners giving a diagnosis that this should be delivered in an unbiased way, and the Department of Health now advises that this screening is now an information process to help make women make informed decisions. However, there is a clear push towards termination in the clip. No other positive alternative is discussed. This is a biased portrayal of a diagnosis situation, which is ill-informed and badly researched, and it sends a negative narrative about Down syndrome that it is something to be feared, and termination is the only option. As a result, Emmerdale perpetrates a negative stereotype by equating Down’s syndrome screening with abortion on-screen.

The actor says the plot has been ‘thoroughly researched’ and they give a ‘balanced view’ which the Emmerdale team have also reiterated, but this is completely misleading the public. The actor herself says she spoke to people ‘who had been through it’ but not to the individuals who have Down syndrome themselves or their families. The Down syndrome community, including the national Down Syndrome Association were not consulted at any stage about the storyline, and how this might impact their lives. 

The only ‘charity’ to be consulted were Arc who are infamously pro-termination. The only views of parents who decided to go ahead featured on their platform instil the same fear which is evident in this clip. https://www.arc-uk.org/for-parents/continuing-a-pregnancy/parents-story-2 . No families from the Down syndrome community were consulted, and this has manifested itself in the biased and discriminatory storyline which perpetuates the negative and offensive narrative that individuals with Down syndrome don't have a right to life, and are not viewed as equals in our society because of the incorrect assumption that they are unable to live full and productive lives, and that they suffer from their condition and will be a burden to all society.  This is incredibly insulting and offensive to the Down syndrome community and their families across the UK, many of whom will be severely impacted by this storyline.  

Emmerdale has offended thousands of people by publicising the outcome of this storyline without an attempt to manage the negative impacts it creates, by failing to consult with the minority group (at any point) before mentioning them in the publicity. 

Lorraine briefly reads a snippet from a letter from a parent of a child with Down syndrome, but then apologises that she can’t read the letter in full, and the platform is given over to the promotion of the storyline.  Once again there was no opportunity for anyone with Down syndrome or their relatives to discuss their concerns. 

The language used throughout when referring to individual with Down syndrome by both Lorraine and Charlotte Bellamy is outdated and offensive. Guidance about positive terminology is now widespread and available from many platforms including the Down Syndrome Association. There was also extensive media coverage about the use of positive terminology around Down syndrome in the media very recently. Both ITV and Lorraine have received positive language guidance on many occasions, but still chose to refer to people with Down syndrome in the third person. Lorraine speaks about a ‘Down syndrome person’, and Bellamy refers to a boy as ‘a Down syndrome’ and ‘Down syndrome son’. This is incredibly insulting and has long been offensive to people with Down syndrome and their families because it suggests a collective, and that the condition is more important than the person. A person is not Down syndrome, they happen to have Down syndrome. Person first language is now widely promoted as being very important to maintain dignity and show respect. Placing the person first and the disability second helps to protect against negative stereotyping that can form as a result of not using positive terminology. If all the parties concerned had taken time to liaise with the many Down syndrome charities and groups, then this would have been the first thing they would have learned as it is the foundation of respect. https://www.downs-syndrome.org.uk/about/terminology-guide/?highlight=positive%20terminology 

Both the actor and the captions ‘urge’ viewers to watch the episodes first before making judgement, but this again is misleading, biased language and is missing the point that the storyline targeting Down syndrome specifically is discriminatory and therefore should not be aired at all. Such comments, which are again echoed by the Emmerdale team, are essentially demonising anyone who speaks out, and it suggests that we are being unreasonable by objecting to the storyline and asking ITV for a review.  We feel that this is an underhand attempt to silence our voice and deprive us of the right to speak up in an effort to ask producers to drop the story which we all feel is discriminatory.  

ITV will not give families an opportunity to speak out to express and concerns when members of our community have tried to respond on a public forum, ITV have taken our comments down and deleted tweets advising about positive language. You can see that comments have been suspended on the trailer link above.  As a result of the Emmerdale trailer our community has also received the most appalling abuse on some social media platforms. Such an ill-informed narrative is damaging to our community and incites hatred towards people with DS and their families and this is evident across social media with statements saying we are selfish to have had a child with Down syndrome, people with DS are a burden on the state and we should be ashamed, and that all people with Down syndrome are severely disabled. This is not the case, and it irresponsible and damaging storylines, accompanied by ignorance and lack of awareness, that perpetuate this false and discriminatory narrative and incite such a negative outpouring of hatred towards the DS community.  

Already the trailer has influenced magazine covers and the wider media, and we are being forced to encounter headlines on a daily basis such as ‘baby agony’ and ‘heart-breaking decision’ accompanied by agonised photos of the actors. The trailer and interview infers that this ‘agony’ is much more preferable to living a life with a child with Down syndrome, and is therefore conjuring a negative image of those families who do decide to proceed with the pregnancy, suggesting they should feel shame and embarrassment because they have brought a child with Down syndrome into the world.

The trailer has sparked a public outcry from the DS community which has now extended to a full media exposure with daily coverage on the radio, TV and in every national and local paper, which has been overwhelming for my family.  To be presented with this every time we turn on the TV or go our to the shops is deeply upsetting and exhausting.  We have already had 2 weeks of anguish with just the trailer being shown, but we have now heard that this storyline will continue throughout December for several weeks over the Christmas period. The thought of this is unbearable. 

Charlotte Bellamy goes on to try to legitimise the storyline by saying that the show features ‘a Down syndrome’ and ‘Down syndrome son’ but this does not justify running a story which is discriminatory.  This show is particularly popular with our community because it features a young boy with Down syndrome, and therefore it is even more insulting that they should even have considered such a damaging storyline. It seems the Emmerdale team have deliberately gone ahead with this controversial stance which is disrespectful to the actor with DS and the audience. I would also have hoped that knowing they have an actor with DS in the cast, that they would have thoroughly researched this sensitive subject and used positive terminology. 

The interview then goes on to discuss another sensitive storyline featured on Emmerdale about dementia, and how training teams now use this for reference, thus alluding that when all the ‘fuss’ dies down this storyline too might be used for such training, but this would not be the case unless it was used to portray completely the wrong way to go about giving a diagnosis,  contrary to the updated health guidelines.  

Individuals with DS face prejudice and discrimination on a daily basis.  Society still struggles to understand Down syndrome due to lack of awareness, and these views are fed by outdated narratives and misguided storylines like this one. The trailer is irresponsible, ignorant and prejudiced and risks further alienating many thousands of individuals and their families. It has already caused a great deal of damage and distress to our communities and undermined the any progress over the last few years giving individuals with Down syndrome equal standing and respect within our society. 

I hope that you will uphold my complaint, and I look forward to hearing your decision