I Challenged Ireland's FOI Decision. They Released More, but Questions Remain.


I know I've been a little quiet with updates lately, but believe me, things have been anything but quiet behind the scenes.
There's a lot more happening with the Pre-1922 Justice Project than what you see posted here. I've been corresponding with government departments, reaching out to individuals and organizations, following up on official correspondence, examining historical evidence, and working on several different avenues to move this investigation forward.
And that's only part of it.
Some developments take time, especially when you're dealing with government departments, historical records, and international correspondence. Others simply aren't ready to be made public yet.
But make no mistake, this project is moving forward. What began as an investigation into a 143-year-old case has grown into something much bigger, and there's a great deal happening beyond what I share publicly.
Now, onto the latest development with Ireland's Department of Justice, because my Freedom of Information challenge has taken another interesting turn.
Back in August, I submitted a formal Freedom of Information (FOI) request seeking government records concerning the development and approval of Ireland's March 2026 policy, which, in principle, excludes convictions imposed before December 6, 1922, from consideration for a Presidential pardon.
I wanted to understand how this decision was reached, what alternatives were considered, and what records supported it.
In September, I received the Department's decision. Some records were released, while others were withheld, and I was left with more questions than answers.
Well, anyone who's been following this project knows I'm not particularly good at accepting an answer that doesn't actually answer the question.
So I formally challenged the decision and requested an internal review.
On November 17, I received their response.
The Department changed part of its original decision and agreed to partially release Record 6, which had previously been withheld.
Now, that's progress. I'll give them that.
But here's where I have a problem.
My internal review wasn't simply about one record. I raised several concerns about the information being withheld, the documents behind the policy, and whether the material released actually explained how the Government reached its decision.
Yet the latest decision specifically addresses the partial release of Record 6, without clearly explaining what happened to several of the other concerns I raised.
And there's something else.
One of the policy documents previously released to me was marked DRAFT.
A draft?
We're talking about a Government policy that was publicly announced in March 2026. So naturally, I'd like to know whether a final approved version exists and, if so, where it is.
I'd also like to understand what records support the decision to use December 6, 1922, as the cutoff and whether other approaches were considered.
These aren't unreasonable questions.
My investigation began with Michael Flynn, Thomas Higgins, and Patrick "Long" Higgins in connection with the 1882 Lough Mask murders.
But this project has grown far beyond three men and one family.
Why should the date of a conviction determine whether a historical case can even be considered for a Presidential pardon? And why shouldn't surviving historical evidence be independently examined, regardless of pardon eligibility?
Those are two separate questions, and that distinction matters.
I've said this before, and I'll say it again.
I'm not asking modern Ireland to accept responsibility for decisions made under British rule more than 140 years ago.
I'm asking why surviving evidence cannot be independently examined.
I understand that Freedom of Information legislation concerns access to existing government records, not an obligation to create explanations that don't already exist.
But that's precisely why I've been pursuing these records. I want to understand what documentation exists, what was considered, and how this policy was developed.
A partial change to an FOI decision doesn't mean every concern has been resolved.
For now, I'm continuing to examine the material received, pursue the outstanding questions, and carry on with the wider work of this project.
And no, I haven't spent all these months digging through 143-year-old history, corresponding with officials, and challenging government decisions just to pack everything away because another letter arrived.
The Banshee is still here. And she's still reading the paperwork.
For those following this investigation, I also encourage you to follow The Pre-1922 Justice Project on Facebook, where I've been sharing more of the historical evidence and discoveries uncovered throughout my research. Some of what I've found raises serious questions about how testimony, witness accounts, and alibis were treated during the original proceedings.
One particularly interesting example concerns Thomas Higgins and an account of him washing potatoes, an ordinary household task that became part of the discussion surrounding his alibi.
There's much more to this investigation than government correspondence, and I want people to see the historical evidence that started this fight in the first place.
The records are still speaking. I'm making sure people hear them.
Thank you to everyone who continues to follow and support the Pre-1922 Justice Project. Even when things appear quiet publicly, there's plenty happening behind the scenes.
Don't Silence the Evidence.
Erin Flynn
Founder & Principal Researcher
The Pre-1922 Justice Project