Amend NC law to require law degree, bar exam, and license for magistrates
The Issue
On August 22 , 2025, the life of Iryna Zarutska was tragically cut short. She fell victim to a grievous oversight by our judicial system in North Carolina. Teresa Stokes, a magistrate judge, decided to release DeCarlos Brown, a man who ultimately became responsible for Iryna's untimely death. This decision was made by a magistrate who was not required by law to be a lawyer. This unthinkable event serves as a wake-up call and emphasizes the need for reform in our legal system.
Currently, under North Carolina General Statute 7A-171.2, magistrate judges are not obligated to possess a law degree, have passed the bar, or even have a license to practice law in NC. This lack of requirement poses a significant risk to the judicious execution of law, as magistrates make pivotal decisions regarding bail, restraining orders, and search warrants. These decisions require a robust understanding of legal principles, something that can only be guaranteed through comprehensive legal education.
Magistrate judges handle around 1.8 million cases yearly. In the year preceding Iryna's death, data showed that North Carolina had over a dozen magistrates who lacked formal legal training, potentially jeopardizing the lives of individuals and the sanctity of justice.
Change is necessary. Revising 7A-171.2 to mandate that all magistrate judges have the proper qualifications will ensure that they possess the fundamental knowledge needed to make informed and just decisions. This requirement will not only benefit the individuals appearing in court but will also bolster public confidence in our judicial system.
These requirements for magistrate judges is not merely a bureaucratic upgrade; it’s an essential measure to prevent further tragic losses like that of Iryna Zarutska. It acknowledges the complexity of legal proceedings and respects the significance of the decisions these judges make daily.
Let's not allow the tragedy of Iryna Zarutska's death to be in vain. Let it be the catalyst for necessary legislative change to protect our community and prevent further tragedies.
Emily RobertsPetition Starter
4
Let’s get to 5 signatures!
The Issue
On August 22 , 2025, the life of Iryna Zarutska was tragically cut short. She fell victim to a grievous oversight by our judicial system in North Carolina. Teresa Stokes, a magistrate judge, decided to release DeCarlos Brown, a man who ultimately became responsible for Iryna's untimely death. This decision was made by a magistrate who was not required by law to be a lawyer. This unthinkable event serves as a wake-up call and emphasizes the need for reform in our legal system.
Currently, under North Carolina General Statute 7A-171.2, magistrate judges are not obligated to possess a law degree, have passed the bar, or even have a license to practice law in NC. This lack of requirement poses a significant risk to the judicious execution of law, as magistrates make pivotal decisions regarding bail, restraining orders, and search warrants. These decisions require a robust understanding of legal principles, something that can only be guaranteed through comprehensive legal education.
Magistrate judges handle around 1.8 million cases yearly. In the year preceding Iryna's death, data showed that North Carolina had over a dozen magistrates who lacked formal legal training, potentially jeopardizing the lives of individuals and the sanctity of justice.
Change is necessary. Revising 7A-171.2 to mandate that all magistrate judges have the proper qualifications will ensure that they possess the fundamental knowledge needed to make informed and just decisions. This requirement will not only benefit the individuals appearing in court but will also bolster public confidence in our judicial system.
These requirements for magistrate judges is not merely a bureaucratic upgrade; it’s an essential measure to prevent further tragic losses like that of Iryna Zarutska. It acknowledges the complexity of legal proceedings and respects the significance of the decisions these judges make daily.
Let's not allow the tragedy of Iryna Zarutska's death to be in vain. Let it be the catalyst for necessary legislative change to protect our community and prevent further tragedies.
Emily RobertsPetition Starter
Support now
Petition Updates
Share this petition
Petition created on September 11, 2025