Andy LamUnited States
Nov 11, 2026

Dear Members of the Chino Valley Unified School District Board of Education,


I am writing to you with an urgent, time-sensitive request as a concerned member of the CVUSD community regarding the recent administrative decision barring five Canyon Hills Junior High 8th-grade students from participating with the Ruben S. Ayala High School Band and Color Guard (BAC) program.


Attached to this email is a PDF containing over 400 electronic signatures from CVUSD parents, students, alumni, and community members—gathered in less than 24 hours and still growing—urging the district to reconsider this decision and allow these students to finish the season and participate in future events.


While we have reached out to district administration, we have received form responses from Assistant Superintendent Dr. Tracy Freed stating that the decision is final and that extracurricular and co-curricular activities are restricted to a student’s own school site. However, this explanation overlooks several critical facts that we respectfully ask the Board to examine:


1. **Established Multi-Year Precedent:** Including feeder-school 8th graders in Ayala’s Band and Color Guard program is a safe, long-standing practice that has operated for years without issue.
2. **No Negative Impact on Junior High Commitments:** Participation in the high school program has never detracted from these students’ academic performance, attendance, or dedication to Canyon Hills Junior High School. In fact, it strengthens the pipeline and enthusiasm for performing arts across both campuses.
3. **Inconsistent Application Across CVUSD:** Other high schools, including within this district, currently allow feeder-school 8th graders to participate with their high school programs. Enforcing this against Ayala creates an unfair double standard for our students.
4. **Full Compliance with Governing Circuits:** Both the Western Band Association (WBA) and Bands of America (BOA) explicitly allow feeder-school 8th graders to compete with their high school ensembles.
5. **Willingness to Cure Paperwork Oversights:** The program and parents were unaware of specific school district forms were needed prior to the Utah trip, and they were never given an opportunity to submit those forms once the issue was raised. Parents and program leadership remain ready to sign any required waivers or agreements immediately to allow them to compete.


These students have already missed out on Utah Regionals and only have two more competitions left in their entire season—including this Saturday. Because district administration has declined to revisit the matter or provide a path to compliance, we are appealing directly to you as our elected representatives. We respectfully ask that the Board of Education to urgently review this matter and to direct the district staff and management to work with the parents on an expedited waiver or clearance to reinstate these students for the remainder of the season.


Thank you for your time, your service to our schools, and your commitment to fairness for all CVUSD students. We look forward to your urgent and timely response!


Respectfully,


Andy Lam
Ayala BAC Booster and Color Guard parent


Link: https://www.change.org/p/allow-8th-grade-bac-students-to-participate-with-ayala-h-s-in-practice-and-competition

 

Attachment: Ayala BAC Petition 11:11:26.pdf