Purushothaman PChennai, India
Jul 7, 2016
Sharing my experience: Theory of oppression: I have made an appeal through change.org to NAAC that before they give score or grade, they shall certify that there is no human rights violation in the institute or university. I didn't get enough support, the requisite five persons, so my appeal didn't go public, although i have sent my appeal directly to the highest officials who can take action. However, i had the doubt whether i was straight forward or people doubted me, or sometimes i used wonder whether i have enough courage. Even, sometimes i used to wonder, i have to make a professional case study, as myself have conflicts- professional. But an event which happened yesterday made me to go a full length as explain as pedagogy of oppression insists that there shall be a theory of oppression which shall lead to a theory of revolution bringing a solution and removing of objects of oppression and the oppression itself. When i say faculty in university are treated as modern type slaves, particularly in the society & trust run private universities and bringing support from NAAC report finding itself on the management attitude and behaviour, i may still go wrong as this is my perception, after all the management are doing their best in circumstances they operate, they have to bribe and keep their name in good stead, the very need of good NAAC grade is one such attempt. Or, even at times, they may not have freedom when we act in particular way. Notwithstanding all these, i will narrate incidents & perceptions i developed, if these are going to be of any help. My PhD guide wanted me to be well placed and he passed an information to contact VC of Veltech, may be this was in June-15 or so, i was well treated and developed high respect for VC, however, i could see his inability to make decision on financial matters, i asked for a salary of 90000 to 100000 per month, he said 70000, i almost got up intending a walk out, he immediately sensed and told me, he would check with management and tell me. Then i have already submitted my phd thesis to madras, almost a year back. A pg degree from IISc year 1980, MBA from IGNOU year 1997. My request for one lakh and a professor post was just as i understood myself with special industrial and academic experience. I had previously worked with Peritar Maniammi University as director and was drawing few years back 70000. Later i was called and offered a lakh as monthly salary and professor post, but there were riders, that we have to give our certificates. And till certificates were given you will be given only 75% of the salary, please note this is as i understand is to have control and check that staff do not leave in the middle of academic year and there were no contract bond. This rider was not discussed by cc or in the discussions but cropped up later when you submit your certificates. There is one sheet letter which states these and forms both receipt and treated as appointment letter. Intact going through the wordings we can not treat this as an appointment letter. Intact they issue another full appointment letter with terms and salary detail which we have to sign and give back, we can't have a copy of this. I was told that few staff misuse the appointment full letter, but it seems the management is misusing as will be seen. We are also told that unless we give back that one page so called appointment letter, we will not be given our original certificates. As my expectations were different than the 75%, i made an application to release 100% of my agreed salary. May be, i have had called for the trouble, i was told that i will be released only 50% only as i have not submitted my ME degree certificate. Whereas i have submitted my BE degree & ME grade showing degree pass in original and stated that ME Degree in original was with Madras University. Later VC had asked me proof that my ME degree original was madras university, which i submitted and satisfied by himself, but could not even to release 75% as per the single page letter. Now, these things were happening, my salary was not released for the first month, was released only on the second month retaining 50% of my salary. The modern type slavery conditions are now evident that your original certificates and huge sums of money are held by management and the formal authority may not or do not have any say on these issues. During this period, i was wondering whether the management is good or bad, and even now I feel the management is good. The management is pro student and very good strategy but faculty are sent out if they showed any dis-obedience, i could be a good candidate, but i should have been sent then only settling all my rightful accounts and certificates, which management may have some trouble explaining. Particularly, i joined the university as a professor, trusting that it is a respectable position, but the management trusts nobody, this only made be to reflect upon the conditions of oppression, think of very young faculty from poor backgrounds when both originals and money are withheld, further the job itself. I requested the HRD manager cum UDHR Article-23 on employment was my action research which could be handled through engineering of school of management to pass my view of breaching of human rights to management and I had also sent emails, except retaining of 50% of salary and sending out of job, thankfully, the management didn't do any bad. During NAAC inspection, i had opportunity to go through their report made in early 2000, which made me and placed in good perspective. My experience in L& T also helped to understand management. During NAAC it was proudly said punishment fees from students and faculty are used as scholarships for deserving students. Now, we can understand that such of these saved money are used for good purpose and not wasted. On the other hand, one may ask whose money, anyhow we see some touch in it. So also, the management supports lots od lower grade sweepers, clerks& people whose livelihood depends on the success of the institution. These people are also under constant threat of losing jobs, but livelihood matters. These were few reasons why i didn't directly disclose the university name in the first place. The pedagogy of oppressed, insists courage to name the oppressor, but the oppressor is not a real oppressor, but an oppressed who imitates the oppressor, as the only solution to get things to work and in order. The management is a minority institution which says the management owns the trust hence the university, accountability, responsivity are evident, which also reflects in one of it's best practice of student mentoring. So, we can conclude the violations are on account of imitating behaviours of oppressor and we can expect management to arrive at better conditions. Theory of revolution: The pedagogy oppressed prescribed solutions which will help all stakeholders, seeing the oppressor as the one who is imitating the oppressor gives room to realign. The management believes in treating faculty under X-theory of workers, where as they are intellectuals and professors of their belief, conviction & specialization require some freedom & head room, and the institute is rightly A-graded, and student and faculty expectation are high. It can't work on x-theory of workers transform itself as a flexible forward looking futuristic international organizations. Rightly the founders and early trend setters have indicated the bridge is made for the future generations to pass through and courage only can or pave new possibilities. The management has to trust itself, trust people, embrace y- theory or modern best suited models and strive it's best to be best university. Do i want the money, i once told the HRD management professor I can just walk out anytime not bothered about money or the certificate, my institute told us, then they can give any number copies of our degree certificates, we have to only write to them. But, what happened yesterday motivated me to write this thesis! I asked the flower vendor lady for three measure length, she said, one measure is twenty rupees, i asked for three but for Rs.50, she shortened the measure, i got angry for her act, later when i reflected back on mine with velltech i felt bad, i don't want anybody to suffer, i want everybody to win, pedagogy of oppressed gives us a method. I have been asking Am Aathmi Party to look into the approach of pedagogy of oppressed and this method bring back the ancient glory to us, corruption free, we can't allow the poor people to suffer, i don't want the sweepers , clerks and others to lose job. I hope the university will issue proper appointment letter copies and don't change the terms on their own will, treat faculty as equal partners in preparing and educating youth, little bit of change attitude from management would help. As DDM Engineers, then we worked on engineering solutions for Human Rights problems on Employment than legal means. Perhaps, i should stay in this approach. Read The Hindu, i don't see much difference, as different managers work with different styles and bring different results, Ms Irani represents women & informal system. Further @NDTV watched Prakash Javadekar – speaking mission & credentials – wish him great success – i dream in our country there will be freedom in education, no restrictions whatsoever, choice based and progress and practice in any profession, quality, value and freedom of highest order. However, i might share an appeal which i require at least five persons to vouch to go public – even I am not disclosing the university name where i gained this knowledge of human rights violation, even though i lost about 2 to five lakhs of rupees as my salary arrears. We have fears & troubles, or sometimes adjust as our culture. Anyhow, we hope, we will get requisite change in our education system and hope, we have a minister who will act & achieve and wishing him all success. The change.org appeal link: Dear All/Sir, Please visit this link and appeal: Why should you appeal - There are universities where faculty are practically under modern type of slavery - which is not desirable. You can bring the change transforming the highest learning institutions to better positions. https://www.change.org/p/all-rectify-any-possible-human-rights-violations-or-issues-if-any-in-universities-in-tamilnadu I am also copying my appeal for your information. I have not mastered/understood the Change.org yet. In fact, I have already marked to the Change makers, namely, NAAC, UGC & HRC through emails: director.naac@gmail.com, sgnhrc@nic.in, cm.ugc@nic.in