Update zur PetitionKeep Newlands Corner family-friendly and free to access!

Objection deadline MIDNIGHT TONIGHT. Here's mine.

Richard HarroldBroadwoodwidger, ENG, Vereinigtes Königreich
21.10.2016
Hello all. Time is running out to get your objections in to the Planning Inspectorate for SCC's application for Commons Consent for the parking charging infrastructure and play trails. Email your objections to commonlandcasework@pins.gsi.gov.uk by midnight tonight. Subject line must be "Common Land at Albury Downs, Newlands Corner (CL34 4) - Surrey County Council". Below is what I've just sent. It might read as a little intemperate, but it is a thorough and comprehensive missive which you can use as guidance for your submissions. --------------------------------------- Dear Sir/Madam, I wish to object to the above application in the strongest terms. It is opposed by some 11,675 signatories to a still-growing petition I created a few months ago, most of whom, like me, are regular visitors to this beautiful, unspoiled site: https://www.change.org/p/surrey-county-council-keep-newlands-corner-family-friendly-and-free-to-access/ I shall hereby demolish every argument in favour of the proposals on grounds of the negative impact they would have on the environment, road safety and public health - as well as their highly dubious financial basis. I beg of you your patience and ask that you read all my arguments in full. The economic arguments SCC have made for the maintenance of the site simply do not stack up. The reported costs (SWT is paid £157,000 a year to manage the toilets, car-park and trails of this 255-acre site - this does not include any woodland management or conservation work, which is the responsibility of the Albury Estate) are vastly in excess of those incurred by other land-owners and managers in the vicinity, such as the Friends of the Hurtwood, who manage in excess of 3000 acres and fifteen car-parks (including woodland management and conservation work) on £70,000 per annum. SCC claims that the costs of running Newlands Corner will rise to a scarcely believable £319,000 per annum once the play trails and parking infrastructure are installed, with parking management alone costing £59,000 a year. They have repeatedly refused to publish their business plan. Furthermore, SCC has argued that a £1 per hour parking charge (rising in each subsequent year) is necessary, on the basis of there being 122,000 cars a year visiting the site. A more recent SCC traffic survey indicates that this is not so: in fact, the true figure is around 255,000. It is clear that their proposals represent catastrophically bad value for money for taxpayers and visitors alike. They claim it is necessary to make SWT cost-neutral: however, spending on the Countryside Estate amounts to just 0.05% of SCC's budget. SCC has stated a desire to increase visitor numbers within four years to 365,000 - a figure which could only be accommodated by a substantial extension of the already very large car-park, which is often filled up completely on busy summer days. In reality, this means that the common would be increasingly tarmaced (SCC are admitting only to plans to "restructure" the car-park, but will not elucidate what this means), and SWT will make at least a 200% profit on the operation of the site, which in turn will fund the large new visitor centre, shop and coach park which has proven such an unpopular idea. At a public meeting, the proposal which you are considering met with unanimous opposition from a large and diverse audience. Not even mere lip-service has been paid to listening to the electorate: we have been completely and utterly disregarded and ignored. There has also been little to no information made available on who will benefit from the substantial profits likely to be generated. On the subject of increased vehicle numbers: the A25 is an ancient route and has not been - and indeed cannot be - the subject of significant safety improvements. The entrance to the Newlands site is a blind entrance on a blind bend atop a blind summit, from both directions. A number of vehicle collisions have resulted, with a few fatalities. Speed has not been a factor: indeed, the only safe way to leave the site, even in a powerful car, is with full throttle, to avoid getting hit from behind. The situation has been exacerbated with a large increase in the volume of glacially slow-moving cyclists, taking up so much road space that safe overtaking is impossible. As a cyclist myself, I never used that section of the A25 for this reason, diverting onto the much more level A248. The only way to resolve this issue is, given the immense elevation change from the Clandon crossroads to Newlands, and then back down to Silent Pool, is to divert the A25 into a new tunnel and reduce the old route to an access road for Newlands Corner, to be reopened to through traffic only in the event of temporary closure of the tunnel I propose. However, as the cost of this is likely to be around half of that of the Hindhead twin tunnels, it would be around the £180-200 million mark - unlikely to be achievable. Indeed, SCC has refused to make even the most minor changes of road layout at the entrance to Newlands, so it is unimaginable that they would contemplate such a large-scale project. Therefore, a major increase in traffic cannot be accepted. No public transport alternative exists, with the nearest railway lines around 2-3 miles away. No bus service stops at Newlands either. Therefore, it is highly likely that the parking charge scheme will create large-scale displacement parking problems in the nearby villages, which are ill-equipped to handle such a volume of parked cars. With an additional 10% rise in the parking charge every year planned by SWT, this will render a day out to Newlands - currently an affordable, healthy and educational pastime for young families, school groups and OAPS - an unaffordable luxury. SWT does not appear to regard this as a problem, with their chairman saying those who can't afford it should go elsewhere. This site has been a freely-accessible piece of common land for many decades, throughout living memory. It is our countryside, our natural heritage, our birth-right. Its commercialisation for profit, to the exclusion of the young, old and disabled, is utterly unacceptable. Even the much-trumpeted £40 season ticket represents exceedingly poor value in comparison to the National Trust's £63 membership fee, which permits free unlimited access to the Trust's 500+ properties. To exclude so many when public health is such a high Government priority, and when it is proven that free access to the countryside promotes both physical fitness and good mental health, is callous and unjustifiable. SCC is also applying - despite a total absence of market research to indicate demand for them - to erect large play structures to the rear of the site, in a designated ancient woodland which is home to a large number of very old yew trees, some of which are thought to be over a thousand years old. The site is also home to a thriving population of hazel dormice, a vulnerable and reclusive protected species which experts regard as endangered. According to The People's Trust for Endangered Species, they are under threat of extinction (and already are extinct in seventeen English counties), their numbers having declined by a third since 2000, and at this site would be severely affected by an increase in noise, disturbance and vehicle emissions. The purpose of the parking charges is purportedly to fund the maintenance of these follies. Of critical importance is the finding in a SWT feasibility study that the parking charge scheme would not be viable without the construction of these edifices. The damage that they would do to the existing sensitive habitat has not been properly assessed (SWT's own ecology study has been largely dismissed as a whitewash), and is likely to be substantial. The chalk grassland at the front is also hunted daily by a substantial number of kestrels, red kites and buzzards, with occasional sightings of other larger migrating raptors, including white-tailed eagles - possibly attracted by the nearby Tillingbourne fishponds. As Newlands is one of the most prominent sites in the Surrey Hills AONB, it is difficult to reconcile the aforementioned damage, and the impact of the parking-charge infrastructure, with the statement by the National Association of AONBs that “an AONB is exactly what it says it is: an outstanding landscape whose distinctive character and natural beauty are so precious that it is in the nation’s interest to safeguard them”. It goes on to say “Because of their fragile natural beauty, the primary purpose of AONB designation is to conserve and enhance the natural beauty of the landscape”. The Association also says that "AONB status provides a context for low key, long-term action, which relies upon partnership with local people". A near 50% increase in visitor numbers in four years, installation of intrusive parking-charge infrastructure and erection of outsize play structures in a site of significant environmental interest and fragility can hardly be called low-key or long-term action - indeed, combined with the contempt shown by SCC to the public, it contravenes this ethos entirely, and flies in the face of all established best practice in nature conservation. Nor can it be said that the proposals are going to benefit the public - between the erosion of the common, exorbitant charging excluding the majority of current visitors and the environmental destruction which will inevitably result, it is hard to see that there can be any argument in their favour. They would totally change the character of what is currently natural common land by transforming it into an artificial tourist attraction. Again, this contravenes NAAONB guidance. It is also demonstrably the case that SCC and SWT have not even been willing to consider alternative models. It is the argument of the campaign group which I founded that the site needs to be removed from the control of SWT and vested in a new charitable trust created for the purpose of managing it on a non-profit basis (as per the Friends of the Hurtwood). We are confident that this could be done on a viable, sustainable, inclusive and environmentally responsible footing at a tiny fraction of the cost supposedly incurred by SWT. Suggestions of this alternative solution to SWT and SCC have been rudely rebuffed without the slightest contemplation. Furthermore, this site falls within the Green Belt. Development in the green belt should only be permitted "in very special circumstances". Newlands is demonstrably not such a case: there is no urgent requirement for this development. The site is entirely sustainable as it is. For those who wish to take children out to a highly-developed activities centre, such facilities exist at Stoke Park in Guildford, and at Alice Holt Forest near Farnham. Newlands is a site for the exploration and enjoyment of unspoiled nature. It is also worth noting that Newlands is a favourite gathering place for numerous classic and sports car clubs, as well as a small army of motorcyclists. They have stated unanimously that these proposals will force them away from the site, in search of a new meeting spot, likely outside the county. As it is, they provide a significant amount of income to the popular existing catering outlet - a much-loved family-run business which will be forced out if SCC's plans are realised in full. At issue here is an incontrovertible moral obligation to uphold the inalienable right of the people to enjoy the outstanding natural beauty of their own landscape heritage. These proposals submitted by SWT and SCC are rooted not in this obligation, but in an avaricious desire to generate as much profit as possible from the commercialisation of the Countryside Estate. Newlands will only be the first site to be so despoiled: similar proposals are already being conceived for Ockham Common, doubtless to be followed by many others. These ruinous schemes are being conceived by high-handed politicians purportedly representing far-flung wards in the distantly-removed County Hall, who, unlike the group of local campaigners which I founded, have little knowledge of this magnificent location or of its community of visitors. We are far better-qualified to care for the site and are not so blinded by arrogance that we will not listen to the public. Therefore, it is imperative that no legal precedent is set by the approval of this disastrous application: it must be rejected in its entirety. The will of the people shall prevail! Yours faithfully, Richard J. W. Harrold 13, Clinton Road, Leatherhead, Surrey, KT22 8NU