
Susanna Wilsonイギリス
2016/03/14
Apologies for the limited information we have been able to share so far about Sunny’s shop, but a lot has been going on behind the scenes since our initial email to you.
To recap, Sunny’s landlord has served him notice under his lease requiring possession on the basis that he wants to convert the property to a private house and live there. If he can demonstrate these grounds, then Sunny will be gone within six months!
Key to the landlord’s argument will be that he has planning permission for the conversion. If permission is granted, then Sunny’s case for remaining will be much weaker. Objecting to the planning has been a major focus of the fight to “Save Sunny News”.
As you know the application for planning permission to change the use of Sunny News from retail into residential was turned down by Wandsworth Borough Council (WBC) but the Landlord appealed and on 27 January this year he had this successfully overturned by a Planning Inspector.
This means that subject to a final period within which the appeal decision can be challenged (a process called a statutory review) consent the will be granted.
This challenge period was six weeks which expired on the 7th March and in that time Sunny has taken advice from local Barristers and Chartered Surveyors who have been acting on his behalf on a pro-bono basis.
WBC also considered the case for challenging the decision and led by Cllr Ravi Govindia met with Sunny and his advisors along with Justine Greening MP, Cllr Walsh, Cllr, Humphries, Cllr Caddy and council officers including the borough solicitor and head of planning. It was put to WBC that there were significant grounds to challenge the decision and whilst WBC agreed to take its own independent legal advice, it has – disappointingly – decided not to seek the statutory review itself.
Whilst Sunny has not been able to rely on the support of WBC to help him fight the decision, having carefully considered the advice he has received and given the strength of his argument that this appeal decision is flawed, he has decided to go it alone and apply for a statutory review himself.
This decision is fraught with risk and potential cost to Sunny, but given the strength of his argument and the threat to his livelihood and home, he feels he has no other option.
The situation Sunny finds himself in is no fault of his own. His initial lease for the shop had expired and had been renewed once and the time had come for it to be renegotiated again. The Landlord had always told Sunny he was a good tenant.
However, during 2015 the law was changed to allow property such as shops and pubs etc, to have their use changed so they could be converted into residential property. The legislation was intended to bring disused properties back into use, as opposed to assisting owners in achieving the closure of successful businesses and evicting their tenants such as Sunny. In many cases, other boroughs have ring-fenced commercial properties with what is called an Article 4 direction, to prevent such situations occurring, but in WBC’s case this has not been done, leaving Sunny vulnerable to the fact that property values have risen considerably in London to a level attractive to the landlord wanting to cash in.
In addition to all of you, Sunny has the support of Justine Greening MP, Baroness Jenny Jones in the London Assembly and Zac Goldsmith who agrees the way the legislation has been applied is flawed (see video — https://youtu.be/5pDou0H6hLo ). However, to date there has been no sign that Government will amend the law and hence Sunny is left to fight the appeal decision alone.
The Statutory Review has been submitted by Sunny. He is facing a difficult situation on many levels and we are sure you will want to continue the fantastic support you have given so far. Your letters, emails and support for the petition have made this issue more visible to decision-makers, so thank you for taking the time and effort to show your support.
You may recall last summer we held a concert to support Sunny where we raised just over £2000. Sunny didn’t ask for this fundraising event, but the community wanted to show their support for him. Issuing the Statutory Review earlier this month cost Sunny £1500 which we were able to pay from the money raised at last years concert.
However, whilst Sunny is not fighting this alone, he is risking significant costs against him if he fails. Hence, we the (Southfields Triangle Residents Association - STRA) are launching a campaign to raise some more funds to support Sunny in his campaign to defeat the Planning Inspector and his landlords claim for possession.
Very soon we will be launching a crowdfunding campaign to invite you to make a donation in support of Sunny. We will send you more details about this campaign as soon as we can.
Once again, many thanks for all the support you have offered so far it is very much appreciated.