Assess high value property using a reasonable comparative

Assess high value property using a reasonable comparative

The Issue

In  New York City, many condominium units and cooperative apartments are assessed by comparing them to similar rent-regulated buildings.   However, many of these units have a market value that is so high there is not a rent-regulated building that can be used as a reasonable comparative.

This  bill  would  allow  the New York City Department of Finance to use either a non-rent-regulated building or a market  rate  assessment  to ensure that property assessments are not artificially deflated.

Failure to do this means high value buildings will continue to be under-taxed due to under-assessment.  Ideally, all property should be assessed primarily on locational values, but if buildings are to be taxed, it's not fair to compare a new, high-value building with lots of amenities, to an older less desirable building in the same neighborhood that is benefiting from years of under-assessment.  This only compounds the injustice and deprives the city of badly needed revenues.

Please pass Bill A07326A, sponsored by Assembly Member Dan Quart.

avatar of the starter
Scott BakerPetition StarterSenior Advisor, Public Banking Institute Board member, Common Ground-USA Building Designer and Originator of the RiverArch: <a href="http://bit.ly/BroadsheetRA1" rel="nofollow">http://bit.ly/BroadsheetRA1</a>
This petition had 41 supporters

The Issue

In  New York City, many condominium units and cooperative apartments are assessed by comparing them to similar rent-regulated buildings.   However, many of these units have a market value that is so high there is not a rent-regulated building that can be used as a reasonable comparative.

This  bill  would  allow  the New York City Department of Finance to use either a non-rent-regulated building or a market  rate  assessment  to ensure that property assessments are not artificially deflated.

Failure to do this means high value buildings will continue to be under-taxed due to under-assessment.  Ideally, all property should be assessed primarily on locational values, but if buildings are to be taxed, it's not fair to compare a new, high-value building with lots of amenities, to an older less desirable building in the same neighborhood that is benefiting from years of under-assessment.  This only compounds the injustice and deprives the city of badly needed revenues.

Please pass Bill A07326A, sponsored by Assembly Member Dan Quart.

avatar of the starter
Scott BakerPetition StarterSenior Advisor, Public Banking Institute Board member, Common Ground-USA Building Designer and Originator of the RiverArch: <a href="http://bit.ly/BroadsheetRA1" rel="nofollow">http://bit.ly/BroadsheetRA1</a>

Petition Updates

Share this petition

Petition created on February 14, 2014