PETITION CLOSED

  • The time period for signing this petition has ended.
Demand New York City Stop Blocking Transgender People From Correcting Birth Certificates
  1. Signatures
    890 out of 2,000
    Petitioning
    1. Health Commissioner, New York City (+ 4 others)
      Petitioning
      close
      • Health Commissioner, New York City (Thomas Farley)
      • New York City Department of Public Health and Mental Hygiene
      • New York City Bureau of Vital Statistics
      • New York City Office of Vital Records
      • New York City Board of Health
  2. Created By
    Michael Jones
    Boston, MA
About this Petition Petition Letter Petition Updates

New York City currently follows outdated and discriminatory regulations that require transgender men and women to undergo genital surgery before the Department of Health will issue them birth certificates with corrected sex designations. This policy, which was put in place more than 40 years ago, means that if a transgender person does not have genital surgery, they cannot have the sex classification on their birth certificate changed, even if they provide ample and extensive medical documentation of their actual sex.

This arcane policy has drawn a lawsuit from the Transgender Legal Defense and Education Fund (TLDEF). TLDEF is representing three transgender people born in New York City who have tried to obtain corrected birth certificates, but have been denied by the Department of Health, even though they have medical documentation that says the "sex designation" on their birth certificates is incorrect and in need of a change.

Noah Lewis, a lawyer with TLDEF, noted that the vast majority of transgender people have not undergone the genital surgery required under New York City's policies. In some cases, there are medical issues that prevent a transgender person from having the surgery. In other cases, the financial burden of accessing the surgery can be too high, especially since most insurance companies don't cover the procedure. 

Yet New York City's current policy turns a blind eye toward these concerns, ignoring the fact that there are other considerations beyond genitalia that determine sex -- including, as TLDEF's formal legal complaint notes, the sex of the brain or one's self-identified sex. This policy actually places New York as an unfortunate outlier as well, given that most states will accept a letter from a doctor certifying a sex change as sufficient documentation to change vital records like birth certificates. 

It's time for New York City to stop following a 40-year-old law that is no longer relevant, and only serves to foster discrimination, harassment, and humiliation. Let the New York City Department of Health know that transgender people should have the right to correct their birth certificates without a forced requirement of genital surgery. 

Why People Are Signing
Recent Signatures

Please change your policy to allow transgender people to correct birth certificates

Dear Commissioner Farley and the New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene,

I'm writing today to urge you to update a Department of Health policy that unfairly blocks many transgender people from updating their birth certificates to reflect their correct sex. As the Transgender Legal Defense and Education Fund (TLDEF) has made clear in a recent lawsuit targeting your Department, New York City currently forces transgender people to undergo genital surgery in order to correct their birth certificate.

But that policy is seriously flawed for a number of reasons. First, many states simply require that transgender people show a medical note from a doctor certifying a sex change in order to correct a vital record like a birth certificate. Second, science and medicine recognize that more goes into determining gender than just genitalia, with the sex of the brain and one's self-identified sex serving as critical factors. Third, genital surgery is not always a possibility for transgender people, given financial constraints (many insurance companies do not cover the procedure), and/or medical constraints (sometimes genital surgery can cause health risks for transgender people).

I urge you to update New York City's policy on this. The current policy only serves to foster discrimination, harassment, and humiliation of transgender people in New York City. That's just not good enough for a city with a reputation that values diversity and acceptance.

Thank you for your time.

[Your name]

Press Inquiries