2 petition

This petition won 4 months ago

Petition to Metropolitan Transportation Authority, Joseph J. Lhota, Andrew Cuomo, Long Island Rail Road

Remove Patrick Nowakowski from his position as President of The Long Island Rail Road

For years now, riders of the Long Island Rail Road have been neglected and treated like absolute garbage by Patrick Nowakowski. Fares keep going up, a monthly pass can cost upwards of $500, and in return you get several trains delayed and/or cancelled on a daily basis, dirty trains, crippling stations, broken rails, signal problems, and a 50/50 chance at getting a train from the 1970's. It's time the Long Island Rail Road began treating its customers with respect, and give us the service that we pay for. It is now January 25th, 2018, and it is also the 25th consecutive day of 2018 in which some problem with the LIRR has caused extreme delays and/or cancellation of trains. Issues range from signal problems, broken rails, etc. There has not been one single day this year where the entire system ran without trouble. Despite all of this, the LIRR claims its on-time performance to be "94%". This is due to the simple fact that the LIRR considers any train that's 5 minutes and 59 seconds late or under to be "on-time". How can a train that's six minutes late possibly be considered on-time? If the grace period were reduced to one minute, "on-time performance" would easily be at around 15-25%. Furthermore, there is a lot of evidence that Patrick Nowakowski seems to solely favor customers on the Babylon branch. Out of all the problems on the LIRR in the past year, the vast majority occur on the main line. That's right, the "main line", which is the backbone of the entire system, isn't treated like the "main line" at all. Instead, the Babylon branch seems to be turning into the LIRR's vision of the "main line". Anybody who lives on Long Island knows that most of the south shore, where the Babylon Line runs through, is the home to Wall Street brokers and investors, aka, the people who really have control in the government. Patrick Nowakowski knows this, and does whatever he can to make sure that these "superior people" are never given a bad riding experience, while us middle-class folks on the Main Line have to deal with daily issues on the LIRR. Concrete rail ties are much more durable and do a much better job and keeping rails from breaking than the standard wood ties. Guess which branch is the only branch that gets concrete ties? The Babylon branch. You can also take a guess as to which branch gets heated indoor platforms - the Babylon branch. Canopies to keep you dry on the platform when it's raining? Trains almost every 15-20 minutes? The Babylon branch - you get the point. Here is some more information to add to the issue that the Babylon branch is getting special treatment. In December of 2017, the LIRR announced that beginning January 8th of 2018, Amtrak would begin work to improve tracks outside of Penn Station, meaning that the timetables would be affected (more limited service). You can read more about this here, but the general consensus among LIRR riders is that the Babylon branch is getting a ton of extra trains, while every other branch is getting screwed over by having trains removed and combined with already overcrowded trains. For example, as seen on the MTA's website, the 5:06 PM express train from Penn Station to Huntington (with a 2016 ridership of 740) will not be operating during these several months, and is being combined with the 5:17 PM semi-express to Huntington (with a 2016 ridership of 1090). The 5:17 PM alone is already crowded enough. There are barely enough seats to accommodate everyone. Now, an additional 740 people will have to board that train and stand, causing dangerous overcrowding conditions. However, the Babylon branch, which already has more trains than all the other branches, is getting ADDITIONAL SERVICE AND EXTRA CARS. These trains are never overcrowded, and there is absolutely no need to be giving them additional service. What sense could this make other than Patrick Nowakowski giving favoritism to the Babylon branch? The Babylon branch is the only branch to get trains every 20 minutes (roughly) during off-peak hours, while some other branches (which are more crowded) have to wait upwards of one hour for the next train. In fact, they even even have an express train during off peak hours (1:05 PM), which is only 17 minutes after a local train (1:22 PM). No other branch has express trains during off-peak hours. It is clearly evident that Patrick Nowakowski is corrupt, and in violation of the MTA's Title VI anti-discrimination policy. We ask for him to be removed immediately.

Mark Davidson
44 supporters
Update posted 1 year ago

Petition to MTA- Joe Lhota, Charles Schumer, Kirsten Gillibrand, Lee Zeldin, Andrew Cuomo, Thomas Croci, Dean Murray

We NEED a 4th LIRR Crossing for the Tri-Hamlet Area!

On Saturday, May 13th, 2017, the MTA/Long Island Railroad undertook railroad crossing renewal work at the LIRR crossing at William Floyd Parkway. The Mastic Beach, Mastic, and Shirley area, known by many as the Tri-Hamlet community, has only 3 LIRR grade crossings for the peninsula. While crossing renewal work was in progress, motorists were only able to use the other two area crossings at Smith Road and Mastic Road. This restriction created car accidents, and backed up traffic for miles, with some residents coming into the area and out of the area having to sit in traffic for between one and two hours, when a typical commute would take under 15 minutes. During normal traffic conditions, traffic backs up at this intersection, especially when there is a train at the station with the gates closed for extended periods of time, during peak travel time, and in the holiday and beach seasons. There have been delays in emergency response times due to traffic congestion in the past when all three LIRR crossings were operational. Economic activity is hindered due to congestion. The area, which was heavily impacted by Superstorm Sandy, has William Floyd Parkway designated as a coastal evacuation route. As evidenced by traffic conditions during the much need grade crossing renewal project, traffic can be at a standstill when this crossing is inaccessible. If there was a disaster in the area, not only will residents not be able to evacuate in a timely manner, but incoming assistance could be hindered due to congestion.  The Tri-Hamlet area has grown exponentially over the past few decades, with over 45,000 people residing in the two hamlets and one Village, a majority of them living south of the railroad tracks. This increase in population did not come with an increase in railroad crossings.  A railroad crossing at Hawthorne Street/Titmus Avenue in Mastic is needed for the area, and is long overdue. There has been pushback from the MTA in the past for this important crossing for the community. We need federal officials to help fund the project through the Federal Railroad Administration, and New York State elected officials and the MTA to move ahead with the plan. 

Friends of Long Island
1,161 supporters