Petition Closed
Petitioning The Prime Minister

The UK government must comply with international law and desist from drone targeted killings, give a detailed account of the legal basis for its targeted killing in Syria and commit to proper oversight and accountability for the use of its armed drones.

In September 2015 Prime Minister David Cameron revealed to the House of Commons that the RAF had undertaken the targeted killing of British national Reyaad Khan in Syria using a British drone. This is the first time that British forces are known to have carried out a targeted killing outside of a United Nations sanctioned military intervention. Legal Scholars and international human rights organisations have professed profound shock at this development but the British Defence Secretary has told the media that other British citizens may now be targeted in this way.

While it may be lawful in certain narrow circumstances to pre-emptively kill a suspect, the growing use of armed drones has hugely expanded the number of targeted killings by states that operate them and international law in this area is quietly being eroded.

The targeted killing in Syria of British citizen Reyaad Khan by an RAF drone (followed three days later by the killing of Junaid Hussain by US forces in co-operation with the UK) has caused huge controversy amongst human rights groups and legal scholars.  Prime Minster David Cameron told the House of Commons that the killing of the two men was legal as “it was necessary and proportionate for the individual self-defence of the UK.”[1]  However it was also suggested that the men were put on a target list earlier in the summer meaning that the killing in August was not in response to any imminent threat.  Legal experts emphasise that to be lawful under the self-defence framework such action must be “instant, overwhelming, and leaving no choice of means, and no moment for deliberation”.[2] 

Further confusing the issue, in the House of Commons David Cameron told MPs that the strike “was not part of coalition military action against ISIL in Syria” while in a formal letter to the United Nations reporting the strike, the UK stated that its military actions in Syria was also “in the collective self-defence of Iraq,” an entirely new and different legal argument.[3]

Transparency and accountability

While the legal arguments are complicated and confusing it is surely right that the government sets out clearly for the public and parliamentarians the legal basis for killing a British citizen in a country in which the UK is not at war and for which UN authority has not been granted. Note this is not the same as asking the PM to publish the formal legal advice it has received from the Attorney General, nor to publish intelligence about this particular strike. 

The activities of ISIS are abhorrent and in many cases barbarous and there is a temptation to sweep aside international, European and domestic law and insist that terrorists are legitimate targets for swift execution.  But that is the way of the mob. Our response to terrorism must not be to abandon the rule of law and embrace unthinking violence as that is just what the terrorists want. Instead we must recommit ourselves to act justly in refutation of the idea that such violence and terror can ever be legitimate. 

 [1] Syria: refugees and counter-terrorism - Prime Minister's statement, 7 September 2015, https://www.gov.uk/government/speeches/syria-refugees-and-counter-terrorism-prime-ministers-statement
[2] The Caroline Case.  The Avalon Project: http://avalon.law.yale.edu/19th_century/br-1842d.asp
[3] http://www.un.org/en/ga/search/view_doc.asp?symbol=S/2015/688

 

This petition was delivered to:
  • The Prime Minister

    Drone Campaign Network started this petition with a single signature, and now has 679 supporters. Start a petition today to change something you care about.




    Today: Drone Campaign Network is counting on you

    Drone Campaign Network needs your help with “Stop British Drone Targeted Killings”. Join Drone Campaign Network and 678 supporters today.