Decision Maker Response
RSPCA NSW’s response
Jul 17, 2018 — Thank you everyone for your interest in this ongoing investigation.
On 20 June 2018 we received footage of dead and dying hens at a barn egg farm. That footage can only be described as truly horrifying. RSPCA NSW Inspectors immediately commenced an investigation, and attended the farm that afternoon.
We had received incomplete intel 10 days prior. During the initial complaint, we were not given an address, and we asked the informant to call back with further information, however that did not happen. With an incomplete complaint, and incorrect information that the police were handling the matter, RSPCA Inspectorate protocol was followed, which meant that RSPCA did not at that time intervene in a police matter.
Between Wednesday 20 June and Friday 6 July 2018, RSPCA NSW attended the Lakesland property every day except for three. On four occasions, RSPCA attended with a Local Land Services District Veterinarian, on a further two occasions, with an expert avian veterinarian, and on another occasion with an industry consultant.
Having found symptoms signs of potential notifiable diseases, samples were taken, and tests were conducted by both vets. Due to the potential of contagious notifiable diseases, biosecurity protocols were instilled.
In accordance with Inspectorate policy, legally binding 24N Written Directions were issued to the owner of the hens to comply with improving welfare standards within a short period of time. On the same day, a number of birds were seized under the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act and remain central to the animal cruelty investigation.
The hens had sufficient food and water every day while inspectors were on site, and welfare conditions were improving.
We attempted to negotiate with the owner of the hens to release some hens to rescue groups, but following an alleged trespass event where activists were allegedly violent and attempted to steal hens, he refused to cooperate with any rescue groups.
Both the Local Land Services veterinarian, and the avian expert veterinarian on separate occasions collected and sent samples for testing. Results were received from both indicating that the flock was positive for Infectious Laryngotracheitis (ILT) - a highly contagious, respiratory disease caused by a herpesvirus. ILT does not pose a risk to human health, however it has a mortality rate of up to 70% in poultry. ILT has a rapid spread, and symptoms were present in the vast majority of the flock. There is no cure for infected birds and they will be carriers of the disease for life.
Consent was given by the producer to the Local Land Services (LLS) for the euthanasia of the flock, for biosecurity considerations, to protect other flocks and industry. This was carried out by a private contractor on behalf of the LLS. LLS is a NSW Government agency.
As LLS were the ones to handle this matter, they are the best agency to contact if you have further questions. However, we can confirm that RSPCA inspectors were on the property to ensure the hens were euthanised humanely.
The owner of the hens remains under investigation by RSPCA NSW for multiple alleged serious animal cruelty offences. Evidence continues to be compiled with a view to consideration of prosecution. While we understand it can be frustrating, it takes time for a robust animal cruelty case to be built and veterinary and other evidence must be compiled.
The RSPCA does not have the power to simply shut an agricultural enterprise down. In serious animal cruelty prosecutions the RSPCA does seek prohibition orders to stop people convicted of these offences from owning animals again, and in many cases the court makes the orders sought.
Penalties for animal cruelty can be up to $22,000 and 5 years in jail, or for a corporation, $110,000.
There is currently a review of the animal welfare legislation in NSW underway. If you support increased maximum penalties for animal abusers, increased powers for the RSPCA and tougher laws, have your say to the Department of Primary Industries before the public consultation period closes at 5pm Sunday 22 July 2018: https://www.dpi.nsw.gov.au/animals-and-livestock/animal-welfare/improving/improving-the-current-legislation-penalties-and-critical-situations