Petition Closed
Petitioning Mind

Referee Boycott of Mind

Every philosopher has, or has a friend who has, a horror story about dealing with Mind.  Email from referees and authors is persistently ignored; authors wait years for decisions, sometimes even long after referee reports are completed; sometimes referees even submit a report only to find out the paper was withdrawn or rejected months before.

Philosophy already has a shortage of prestigious, generalist journals.  Mind's practices effectively make that list one item shorter.  Junior scholars are especially harmed by Mind's negligence since time is at a special premium for them. 

Until Mind takes serious steps to ensure that (1) email is answered promptly, (2) decisions are issued within 3 months (4 in exceptional cases), and (3) referees are kept informed about the ways their reports will/will not be used, I will not referee for Mind.

This petition was delivered to:
  • Mind

    Jonathan Weisberg started this petition with a single signature, and now has 28 supporters. Start a petition today to change something you care about.




    The only way Mind will listen

    Every signature matters and makes the petition more powerful. Add your name today and help us win.