Updated September 2013 to reflect actions by the California State Legislature
The San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge should be named to honor its original 19th-century visionary.
The San Francisco eccentric, Joshua Abraham Norton (c.1818–1880) — the self-styled "Norton I, Emperor of the United States and Protector of Mexico" — was indeed an eccentric. Some considered him certifiable.
But Emperor Norton also was a visionary. He was a champion of racial and religious unity; an adversary of political corruption; an advocate for fair labor practices; a supporter of women's suffrage; a defender of the people's right to fair taxes and basic services, including well-maintained streets and streetcars; and a general ambassador of his adopted city, who embodied and heralded the values of tolerance and the common good that came to be identified with San Francisco, Oakland and the Bay Area.
In January 1872, Emperor Norton issued a proclamation that declared, in part:
"Whereas, we observe that certain newspapers are agitating the project of bridging the Bay; and whereas, we are desirons of connecting the cities of San Francisco and Oakland by such means; now, therefore, we, Norton I, Dei gratia Emperor, do hereby...order that the bridge be built from Oakland Point to Telegraph Hill, via Goat Island [now Yerba Buena Island]."
In a second proclamation, in March 1872, the Emperor specified that the bridge should be a suspension bridge [emphasis added]:
"The following is decreed and ordered to be carried into execution as soon as convenient: That a suspension bridge be built from Oakland Point to Goat Island [now Yerba Buena Island], and then to Telegraph Hill; provided such bridge can be built without injury to the navigable waters of the Bay of San Francisco."
He repeated this decree with a third proclamation, in September 1872
"ordering the citizens of San Francisco and Oakland to appropriate funds for the survey of a suspension bridge from Oakland Point via Goat Island; also for a tunnel...."
[See the Resources section below for a link to view all three proclamations, as they originally appeared in The Pacific Appeal newspaper.
In adding, for consideration, the possibility of a cross-Bay tunnel — something he originally had called for in a separate proclamation in June 1872 — Emperor Norton anticipated by more than a century the 1974 opening of the Transbay Tube, which carries four of the five lines of the Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) system under the Bay.]
:: :: ::
In essence, the Emperor's vision for a cross-Bay bridge came to pass in 1936, with the opening of the San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge, known as "the Bay Bridge."
In fact, the "bridge" is a bridge system composed of two bridges. The monumental Western crossing, or "span," connecting San Francisco to Yerba Buena Island, is a suspension bridge, as the Emperor specified. The original Eastern crossing, connecting the island to Oakland, was built as a more conventional (at the time of its construction) cantilever-and-truss bridge.
The new Eastern crossing that opened in early September 2013 is a different kind of suspension bridge than the Western crossing.
But, in its way, the new crossing brings to full flower Emperor Norton's original vision of 1872, and makes it an especially appropriate time to finally name the entire Bay Bridge for him.
BUT, WAIT, DIDN'T HALF THE BAY BRIDGE JUST GET NAMED FOR WILLIE BROWN?!!
Well, yes and no.
Certainly, it's true that, on 12 September 2013 — following an earlier 68-0-10 vote by the California State Assembly — the California State Senate, on a 26-7-6 vote, passed a nonbinding resolution (Assembly Concurrent Resolution No. 65, or ACR 65) to name the Western crossing of the Bay Bridge for former California Assembly Speaker and former San Francisco Mayor Willie Brown.
But here's the thing. Even the advocates of ACR 65 have not suggested that the passage and implementation of ACR 65 would — or should — signify the end of the larger entity known as the "San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge."
Indeed, the 2013 Named Freeways, Highways, Structures and Other Appurtenances in California — the most recent edition of the authoritative listing produced regularly by the California Department of Transportation (Caltrans) (see Resources, below) — has separate and independent listings (p. 43) for both the "Willie L. Brown, Jr., Bridge" and the "San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge." The former is listed with a citation for ACR 65, the latter is listed as "Not Officially Named."
In other words: For naming purposes, the State of California places these two things — (1) the constituent "spans" of the Bay Bridge and (2) the bridge as a whole — on two separate planes. Which means that the naming of the Western crossing of the Bay Bridge for Willie Brown and the naming of the entire Bay Bridge system for Emperor Norton is not an either-or proposition — it can be both-and.
The Willie Brown name now functions as one "subtitle" of the larger landmark.
But the main title of the landmark — "San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge" — remains.
Addressing this main title is the opportunity and the imperative highlighted in this petition to name the Bay Bridge for Emperor Norton.
This could be done either by...
(a) renaming the bridge, i.e., replacing the name "San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge" with a new name honoring Emperor Norton and new highway signs reflecting this name
or — following established state precedent — by...
(b) simply *adding* an official "Emperor Norton" name — say, "Emperor Norton Bridge" — to stand *alongside* the "Bay Bridge" name, with a single prominent overhead highway sign on either end of the bridge to memorialize the "Emperor Norton" name.
In this second scenario, the unofficial name "San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge" and nearly all existing highway signs for this name would be left in place.
WHAT THE EMPEROR'S VISION HAS DONE FOR THE BAY AREA
It's been widely recognized, since the opening of the Bay Bridge system in 1936, that the entire system — both Western and Eastern crossings, connected in the middle by Yerba Buena Tunnel — is a remarkable feat of architecture and engineering.
But it's not solely Emperor Norton's 1872 calls for the technical achievement of a Bay-spanning bridge connecting San Francisco with Oakland that better warrants the Bay Bridge system's bearing his name.
What must be kept firmly in mind is that, in calling for a cross-Bay bridge, Emperor Norton also was planting the seed of inspiration that would enable those after him to water and reap the deeper possibility of what such a bridge could do — namely, to nurture the two-way commerce of goods, ideas and influence between people on both sides of the Bay.
From this perspective, the Emperor can be seen as an early, if unwitting, visionary of the whole idea of a local "regional economy."
Indeed, whatever the Emperor's specific intentions in calling for a cross-Bay bridge 140-plus years ago, it seems undeniable that a major result of the Bay Bridge system has been to facilitate and nurture such an economy, to the benefit of people on both sides — and that, without a bridge system connecting San Francisco and Oakland, we would not mean the same thing by "Bay Area" as we do today.
Although, to be sure, Emperor Norton is identified as a San Francisco figure, the Emperor's prescient proclamations calling for a cross-Bay bridge have blossomed, in the hearts and minds of succeeding generations of Bay Area visionaries, into a profound recognition that Oakland needs San Francisco — and that San Francisco needs Oakland.
:: :: ::
Especially with the opening of the new Eastern crossing as a suspension bridge, the 142-year-old vision that the larger landmark bridge system fulfills — the vision of a Bay-spanning suspension bridge that unites the people of San Francisco, Oakland and the East Bay via Yerba Buena Island — a vision that has shaped the lives of generations of the area's residents and visitors — this vision is specific to Emperor Norton.
If the Bay Bridge is to be named for anyone, it should be named for him.
In recognition of this — and whatever names might be given to the constituent sections of the San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge (the West Bay Crossing, the East Bay Crossing and Yerba Buena Tunnel)...
This petition calls on the State of California to name the entity known as the "San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge" after Emperor Norton.
:: :: ::
This petition is the impetus for a new organization launched in September 2013
THE EMPEROR'S BRIDGE CAMPAIGN
Media coverage of this petition
WALL STREET JOURNAL — http://ow.ly/ReSZG
HOODLINE — http://ow.ly/ReSEV
SFist — http://bit.ly/12YCvfc & http://bit.ly/153c5Z9 & http://bit.ly/13Ok8YJ
SAN FRANCISCO BAY GUARDIAN — http://bit.ly/13kBiz3 & http://bit.ly/17DcBeE
SAN FRANCISCO CHRONICLE — http://bit.ly/17nSr9K & http://bit.ly/16lnhCI
KQED — http://bit.ly/1dbjOWV
LOS ANGELES TIMES — http://lat.ms/1aqM2vy
LAUGHING SQUID — http://bit.ly/145wjfy
SAN JOSE MERCURY NEWS (and others) — http://bit.ly/1c19SPb & http://bit.ly/1fX70mj
GOOD DAY SACRAMENTO (local CBS morning show) — http://cbsloc.al/17xdZ2B
JAMIE ZAWINSKI (Mozilla and Netscape co-founder) — http://bit.ly/1464u6P & http://bit.ly/14n6gVW
THE RAW STORY — http://bit.ly/14vGqud
MISSION LOCAL — http://bit.ly/1eHMCrA
Articles on Emperor Norton
Short Documentary Film on Emperor Norton
Named Freeways, Highways, Structures and
Other Appurtenances in California (2013)
Text of Assembly Concurrent Resolution No. 65
("The Willie L. Brown, Jr., Bridge")
Policy on Measures Naming Highways
or Structures | California State Senate
Transportation & Housing Committee
Analysis of ACR 65 by the State of California's
nonpartisan Office of Legislative Counsel
John Lumea started this petition with a single signature, and now has 5,260 supporters. Start a petition today to change something you care about.