Petition to remove Judges Dee McDonald, Hugh Haynie Smith, Joseph P. Weber from Office
Petition to remove Judges Dee McDonald, Hugh Haynie Smith, Joseph P. Weber from Office
I should first start by saying I was inspired to tell my story after reading Lisa Mothee's petition to remove a judge in Philadelphi a Family Court for clearly breaking the law and in hopes that someone reads this story and more people come forward with theirs if these judges are invoved. After, all it is a judges job not to be bias and to protect the interest of the children that come before them in family court. My case is far more complex because there are at least five judges involved in this Senior Judge Nichola s South and Judge Marsha Owens Howser of Scott Superior Court in Scottsburg Indiana, Judge Joseph P. Webe afterr of Clark County Circuit Court Jeffersonville, Indiana and Judge Dee McDonald and Judge Hugh Smith Haynie of Jefferson County Family Court Louisville, Kentucky. All of the judges involved are abusing The Uniform Child Custody and Enforcement Act (UCCJEA) established in 1997 to prevent acts like these from occurring. As well as Indiana Code 31-21-5-1 Jurisdiction and Kentucky Family Court Rules of Practice and Procedure FCRPP24 Transferring. The Judicial Code Of Conduct for their respective state regarding bias, prejudice, harassment , ensuring the right to be heard, and their failure to report both Judicial and lawyer misconduct. They are willfully and knowingly violating parental rights, lack of providing due process in court proceedings and creating Judicial parental alienation through their actions. Now Judge Hugh Smith Haynie has brought CPS of Kentucky on board for the state and is going to hold a trial on August 15,2018 and try and charge me with parental alienation in regards to my children not visiting their father which you will see by a preponderance of evidence contained herein is completely fabricated in order for a presumptive outcome of the idea of what really took place to ensure due process does not occur.https://youtu.be/BtKz7UtJgOY
This all began shortly after my divorce was finalized in August 2008. By September 2008 Brian Dobson was in trouble by Child Protective Services in Indiana for improper discipline of Zackery Dobson. After a visit with his father Zackery returned with bruises, cuts and welts on his body. ( See CPS report from Indiana) Kentucky Judge Dee McDonald would first become involved in 2008 because it was Kosair Children's Hospital that made the initial report. Brian Dobson and his mother Hel Dobson would later testify in Jefferson County family Court that Brian Dobson had hit Zackery Dobson with a flyswatter and Helen Dobson was present. As a result an Emergency Protective Order was issued and Helen Dobson was to supervise Brian Dobson's visits for the next six months. Senior judge Nicholas South in Indiana would then order us not to seek any more protective orders against each other. Then in 2011 Senior Judge Nicholas South ordered us to see Maria Burks at 201 Jeans Drive Salem, Indiana 47167 (812)883-4877 to address Brian Dobson's concerns over our children living with me. It was Maria Burks conclusion that Zackery Dobson needed ongoing therapy to address his ADHD and Samuel Dobson needed therapy on an as needed basis and our daughter Emma Dobson did not need therapy and custody of the children was left with me. Both Brian Dobson and myself were ordered to participate in therapy and we were to consult Maria Burks before we were allowed to file any more motions with the Scott County Superior Court per Senior Judge Nicholas South. However, Judge Nicholas South ignored his own court orders and Brian Dobson kept filing motions in court. This was until 2014 when Senior Judge Nicholas South would dismiss the case due to lack of jurisdiction because my ex-husband Brian Dobson no longer lived in Indiana and had moved to Tennessee and remarried. This action by Senior Judge Nicholas South prevented the children's therapist from testifying after Senior Judge Nicholas South's own Court appointed therapist had recommended these services be put in place. It should be noted that Raliegh Campbell who was acting as my attorney at the time who is now a prosecutor in Scott County Indiana had filed a motion to allow the therapist to testify by phone stating that it would not be prejudice to another party involved and he also provided Senior judge Nicholas South a letter from Diana Hardin the children's therapist at the time and her recommendation once again was that Zackery Dobson should stay with me and both adults needed to be on the same page and that Brian Dobson with whom she had met with was incouraging Zackery Dobson's behavior. However, In April 2015 Brian Dobson would come to Kentucky and Kidnap Zackery Dobson and then take him to Indiana and seek an Emergency Protective Order to keep me away from Zackery Dobson which Judge Marsha Owens Howser issued after Jeff Metiizimier 600 West Jefferson Street #1150 Louisville, Kentucky 40202 starting investigating my claim of parental interference which immediately got dropped due to the issuance of the Emergency Protective Order in Indiana. After conferring with one another by phone Judge Dee McDonald of Jefferson County Family Court would once again allow Senior Judge Nicholas South to retain jurisdiction of the case in Indiana claiming we had a history there. Then Judge Nicholas South and Judge Marsha Owens Howser would recuse themselves under Trial Law 79(H) after insuring that all issues that came before the Jefferson County Family Court would automatically be transferred to Indiana and the Judge Joseph P. Weber was appointed.
This now brings us to Brian Dobson's Motion of Intent to relocate to Scottsburg, Indiana from 1383 Oak Plains Road Ashland City, Tennessee 37015 on July 11,2016 and It was heard on July 29,2016 resulting in an order from Judge Joseph P. Weber to return custody of Zackery Dobson to me. Immediately after Brian Dobson returned Zackery Dobson to me Brian Dobson he began harassing me by sending threating text messages.https://youtu.be/m9SP4OzsTrg Then by November 23, 2017 Brian Dobson had convinced CPS in Louisville, Kentucky that he wanted custody of Zackery Dobson only after Brian Dobson and his sister Billie Jo Mivealaz called police in Louisviille, Kentucky making false reports of abuse in order to get CPS in Kentucky involved. Since their brother Christopher Dobson is an officer at Louisville Metro Corrections they were abusing this by having him intervene and call in favors for them. This eventually lead to CPS in Kentucky forcing me to give custody of Zackery Dobson back to his father or they threatened to take me to court and take our other two children from me. So I signed their Safety Plan and Zackery Dobson was returned to his father and Billie Jo Mivealaz and Brian Dobson managed to convince CPS they were trying to help so I was made to allow Samuel Dobson to stay with Billie Jo Mivealaz until I set up therapy for Samuel Dobson which I did on December 5,2017. In order to cause more problems Samuel Dobson's therapist Christie Brooks Centerstone Louisville, Kentucky called the police and then left my home claiming Samuel was out of control only after she found out I had been recording her visits in my home. Christie Brooks actions were in complete retaliation as I was only trying to protect my kids and myself because no one would listen to me. On December 15,2016 Brian Dobson would file a motion to relocate to 1371N 1350W Deputy, Indiana 47230 saying he needed more room to accommodate the needs of Zackery and Samuel Dobson and Elisha Ellis Kentucky CPS worker had been notified. However, you will see from the facilitated staffing Action Plan Held by Dennis Hefton and Ellisha Ellis on December 1,2016 it will reflect that Samuel Dobson was to be returned to me after I arranged therapy with Christie Brooks with Centerstone formerly Seven Counties which I did. However, when Christie Brooks came for the appointment with Samuel and I Christie Brooks became very hostile after learning that I had been recording the therapy sessions in my home. Christie Brooks would in fact call the police and report that Samuel Dobson was out of control after learning this as retaliation. By December 24,2016 Zackery Dobson had been removed from Brian Dobson's home because he would tell authorities in Indiana that he had been being beaten and starved being forced to work for food and that the home Zackery Dobson and Samuel Dobson now shared with their father was a former meth lab that had never been cleaned. Zackery Dobson had witnessed his father sign a lease with the owner of the property at 1371N 1350W Deputy. Indiana stating that he would not sue the owner if our sons became ill from loving in the home. This lead Judge Darrell Auxier to rule in Cas# 39C01-1612-JS-06 at an order of detention hearing that Zackery Dobson had a reasonable basis for requesting not to be released released to his father so he was placed in Pathways Youth Shelter in Madison, Indiana . Zackery stayed in Pathways Youth Shelter from December 24,2016 until June 2,2017 until Brian Dobson would file and Amended Verified Petition to Modify Custody and Parenting Time. Child Support, and Petition for Contempt Citation stating that he no longer wanted custody of Zackery Dobson but he wanted to keep Samuel Dobson. At the conclusion of this hearing Jennifer A. Joas 413 East Main Street Madison, Indiana 47250 (812)265-1616 would tell me they were acting together to do this to me on purpose. I emailed Jennifer A. Joas after the hearing to remind her that she was given the details of the situation as soon as I retained her services but failed to act or to contact CPS and report child neglect and abuse. To which she would answer my email denying she knew but then going on to say that it didn't matter anyway.
This now brings us to the situation with our other son Samuel Dobson. If you remember Samuel Dobson was suppose to be returned to me in December 2016 but Brian Dobson and his sister Billie left the state of Kentucky and moved Samuel to Indiana. In September of 2017 I would apply for a protective order in Jefferson County Family Court because Brian Dobson was now refusing me visitation with Samuel Dobson unless I allowed him to come to my home. I felt a protective order was needed due to what Brian Dobson had done to Zackery Dobson just months earlier as he no longer wanted any contact with his father. Also, the fact that he had a history of stalking me and taking photos of my home and people that may be visiting us. As well as the fact that Brian Dobson was using CPS as a means by which to intimidate and control Zackery Dobson and myself. However, Judge Hugh Smith Haynie would deny my protective order but appoint Vanessa Durham to act as an Attorney at Litem for Samuel Dobson to which she would decide to leave Samuel Dobson with his father. On October 20,2017 once again we would return to court in Indiana I was then threatened by Judge Joseph P. Weber he said to stop trying to go around him and that he would never give me custody of Samuel Dobson to me again. As retaliation for trying to obtain a protective order he would the order me supervised visit with Samuel Dobson for the next six months and only add Emma Dobson to those requirements so he would not seem bias. I'm wondering if the fact that I reached out to Dr.Phil about this situation has angered the Judge as well. I received a reply back from one of Dr.Phil's producers saying no one would return his calls.
So this brings us to February 12, 2017 when Samuel Dobson would phone me in the middle of the night while Brian Dobson was gone to work and tell me that Brian Dobson had been hitting him and he asked me to call the police so I did. As, a result Brian Dobson would immediately file A motion to Modify Custody of Samuel on February 16,2017 and request that I take same immediately. So I picked Samuel Dobson up that very afternoon. However, by April 2017 I would phone CPS in Kentucky because Samuel Dobson was out of control and was harming others in the home. I had told the person taking the report that I had filed a motion to get Emergency Custody Of Samuel Dobson on February 16,2017 and what Judge Joseph P. Weber had said in October. So, the police became involved and I showed them the papers that both Brian Dobson and I had filed in Indiana and they themselves took Samuel Dobson to Kosair Children's Hospital for a mental evaluation and the hospital kept him. Samuel Dobson would then threaten not to go to school anymore once he was released from Kosair Children's Hospital. CPS worker Ashlea Dodsworth would then visit my home claiming to be there to help she told me she would apply for Emergency Custody for me and talked about helping me get Samuel Dobson put in a residential program so he would go to school and get therapy.
So on April 30, 2017 attorney Melinda Wandzilak 2950 Breckenridge Lane #11 Louisville, Kentucky 40220 (502)454-5019 was appointed to me and she asked the state to take custody of Samuel Dobson in order to place Samuel in therapy to address his behavior. I was told this was temporary, I provided CPS worker Ashlea Dodsworth with Brian Dobson's current contact information and was told she had to use what was in the state system in Kentucky to find him. This conversation took place prior to entering the courtroom and Melinda Wandzilak was a witness to it. The judge on the Emergency Docket that day In Jefferson County Family Court would then appoint Sarah Huyck 600 West Main Street Suite 100, Louisville, Kentucky 40202 (502) 653-9529 who was also present at the April 30,2017 hearing to replace Melinda Wandzilak. However, when I phoned her office Sarah Huyck would deny knowing she was ever appointed. https://youtu.be/keIpoMs1KzQ Then on June 2, 2017 attorney Sarah Huyck was replaced by Thomas Ebendorf 802 Lily Creek Road # 101 Louisville, Kentucky 40243 (502) 585-2100 and appointed to represent me. I phoned Thomas Ebendorf and informed him that I would like to request a different judge in Kentucky because Judge Hugh Haynie Smith was clearly biased and I could show that Judge Nicholas South and Judge Marsha Owens Howser who had in 2015 were bias as well and they had admitted it after doing Brian Dobson a favor by issuing him an Emergency Protective order in Indiana which breaks Indiana's Judicial code of conduct because the protective order was issued only to give Brian Dobson a procedural advantage. Thomas Ebendorf would then say he was not an Indiana attorney so he could not help me because this was an Indiana case. It should be noted that at this time Judge Hugh Smith Haynie would replace Brian Coomer 429 W Muhammad Ali Blvd #605 Louisville, Kentucky 40202 who was appointed to be Samuel Dobson's attorney ad litem with attorney at ;item Vanessa Durham which Judge Hugh Smith Haynie had appointed in September of 2017 after lying about having heard any information in regards to the issuance of an EPO to insure the outcome of this case. Vanessa Durham has been in trouble with the Indiana Supreme Court on November 5,2007 for causi9ng a ;ack of opportunity to be heard and thereby effecting due process signed by Randell T Shepard Chief Justice Indiana. (See attached link) Clearly they keep giving me different attorneys in order to effect due process as well as the attorney themselves refusing to review information or claiming they didn't know they were the attorney. I was also told by Thomas Ebendorf that I could not seek another attorney because I was made to sign an agreement because I can't afford one.
Then on August 3,2018 we go back to court in Indiana because Brian Dobson filed an Intent to relocate to Tennessee once again on July 2,2017 if you remember he lived there in 2014 when Judge Nicholas South dismissed the case due to lack of jurisdiction, in 2016 he filed an Intent to relocate to Scottsburg, Indiana stating their was a significant change in living conditions (This was the first time custody of Zackery Dobson was given back to me since 2015 when Brian Dobson kidnapped him), and now Brian Dobson is asking to move back to Tennessee again. Even though I filed an objection to Brian Dobson's intent to move and I stated all of the facts as they relate to this case contained in the court documents that Judge Joseph P. Weber was either ignoring or working to keep off court record by obstructing my right to be heard. Judge Joseph P. Weber would say that we weren't here to discuss what happened to Zackery Dobson. Even though he knows there is a direct correlation as the events unfolding with Samuel Dobson are exactly the same. Judge Joseph P. Weber would also say " You married him" . In past years Judge Joseph P. Weber had said that I was going to do whatever Mr.Dobson wanted. Clearly this is the case because one could argue that Brian Dobson only wanted Zackery Dobson to use as a tax deduction to catch Brian Dobson up on his child support that he was behind on by almost $8000 when he kidnapped Zackery Dobson in 2015. As soon as Brian Dobson got caught up on his child support he would bring Zackery Dobson back to Indiana from Tennessee claiming when he testified that him and his wife were divorcing. After all Judge Joseph P. Weber and Judge Nicholas South have given him a great incentive to act in this manner by ordering him to pay $14 a week in child support for Emma Dobson our daughter and which ever one of our sons they leave in my custody at the time. As if that wasn't enough now Judge Joseph P. weber has ordered that Brian Dobson is allowed to claim the children on his taxes because Indiana law says as long as you are current on your child support you have to alternate years of claiming them. Even though federal IRS tax laws state that the parent that pays more to support the child as well as who the child resides with the majority of the year shall dictate who claims the child unless a court order exists stating otherwise. It should be noted that Brian Dobson was the one who initiated all of the motions that were filed in Indiana in which he tried to get custody multiple times but the only end result was his child support being lowered. When Kentucky tried to get involved to collect child support so payments would not be collected by Indiana and then given to Kentucky to pay me Indiana would not relinquish its right to collect even though Brian Dobson was not a resident then. You may be wondering why Brian Dobson only chose to keep Samuel Dobson it is because he gets a disability check. I was able to obtain records from the Social Security office when Samuel Dobson came to live with me again on February 16,2018 and they show Brian Dobson is only providing his income and not his wife's. Brian Dobson has been misleading the Social Security Office in order to get Samuel Dobson's benefit check I would assume by claiming to be separated from his wife. When his wife Angela Eads knows about the girlfriend Darlene Burns in Indiana and has since 2015. Despite all of these facts Judge Joseph P. Weber has ordered that Brian Dobson is allowed to move Samuel Dobson to Tennessee.
Then comes the issue of the charges against me alleging that I am guilty of Parental Alienation which are completely false of which I am to appear on August 15, 2015 under CPS case # 18J502131-001 in Jefferson County Family Court in Louisville Kentucky in Judge Hugh Smith Haynie's courtroom. The CPS report written by Ashlea Dodsworth 200 Juneau Drive Louisville, Kentucky 40243 (502) 574-6775 is hear sworn testimony and is not totally true. In paragraph one I never said that Emma stayed with her grandparents while I went to work. I said Emma stayed home with Zackery and Samuel stayed with his grandparents while I worked. In paragraph two Ashlea Dodsworth writes that Samuel's absenteeism became a problem after his stay in Kosair Children's Hospital and worsened when CPS placed Samuel with my parents on April 30,2018 after I asked him to be put in therapy and school at Our Lady Of Peace's Crossroads program which she assured me she was going to do. Ashlea Dodsworth lies once more in paragraph 3 stating that Brian Dobson has custody of both Zackery and Samuel Dobson out of Indiana. Zackery Dobson was released from Pathways Youth Shelter in Madison, Indiana on June 2,2017 and custody was given back to me after attorney Greg S. Morin 223 Ease Main Street Madison, Indiana 47250 (812) 273-0133 filed an Amended Verified Petition to Modify Custody, Parenting time, Child Support and Petition for Contempt Citation where in point 10 Brian Dobson states that he no longer wants custody of Zackery Dobson stating Zackery has psychological problems and he no longer wanted custody of Zackery Dobson. Zackery Dobson was diagnosed with ADHD at the age of 4. In paragraph 4 Ashlea Dodsworth again lies Zackery Dobson and his friend stopped at the grandmothers home to report to me what Samuel Dobson just did at my home. Samuel had tried to bust the window out of Zackery Dobson's friend's car with an umbrella stand. The grandmother called police and filed a false police report in an attempt to get CPS to take my sons. As the grandmother had been doing since 2016 because the children are now either old enough to work or to stay home while I go to work so she has no way to profit money wise off of them anymore. As for Samuel Dobson refusing to go to the doctor or me trying to get mental evaluations totally false I didn't have custody so I could not do that. In paragraph 5 Ashlea Dodsworth lies once more prior to any involvement with his father Brian Dobson Samuel Dobson when to all doctors appointments and again he had none scheduled because I did not have legal custody. My sons do not use weapons to harm one another and they never fought until this whole mess started. It should be noted that I told Ashlea Dods worth that both of my sons have been turned on each other by there father which she does not report. When Samuel Dobson came home on February 16, 2018 he tells Zackery Dobson that dad said you are stupid and that's why he never did anything for you. On August 31,2016 when Zackery Dobson came home he said to Samuel Dobson dad said he didn't want you only me. The only true thing Ashlea Dodsworth says is that Samuel Dobson does not know why he fights and doesn't plan to stop. Ashlea Dodsworth also states that the father Brian Dobson has no substantiated CPS history but she fails to mention the report from 2008 that was substantiated both in Indiana and Kentucky that prompted Dee McDonald to issue an EPO. Then you have CPS's involvement in 2016 as stated on the recording that lead one month later to Zackery Dobson's removal from Brian Dobson's home after CPS in Kentucky failed to listen to my concerns,