Petition Closed

Enough is Enough! Justice for two German Shepherd Puppies from Youngstown, Ohio

This petition had 4,573 supporters

On January 30, 2012, authorities were called to a horrifying scene of animal abuse in Youngstown, Ohio. Behind a Western Reserve Transit Authority bus station, two 6 week old German Shepherd puppies lay dead in the snow. Around their necks and feet were an intricate system of knotted shoelaces, tied in such a way that every time these puppies struggled to get free, the noose around their necks tightened a little bit more. Between the strangulation, the freezing temperatues, and the snow-packed ground, these two puppies didn’t have a chance; they had been dead for hours by the time help arrived.

The man accused of this horrendous, soulless crime is William Bednar, a 53 year old homeless man who is no stranger to the legal system. He has been found guilty of animal cruelty twice before – once in 2000 and once already this year. While there is no record of his sentencing from the 2000 case, Bednar served jail time and is still on probation from his latter sentencing.

It’s easy to see that Bednar’s earlier convictions have done little, if anything, to deter him from committing such cruel acts against animals. Bednar’s evil and senseless crimes need to stop.

This petition asks that, if convicted of two counts of cruelty to companion animals, Bednar be sentenced to the maximum penalty available under law, and that he never be allowed to own animals.


Photo courtesy of

This petition will be updated as more information becomes available; however, the intent will remain the same.

Today: Hand is counting on you

Hand 4Paws needs your help with “Enough is Enough! Justice for two German Shepherd Puppies from Youngstown, Ohio”. Join Hand and 4,572 supporters today.