American Medical Association: Stop defining "obesity" [sic] as a disease!

Reasons for signing

See why other supporters are signing, why this petition is important to them, and share your reason for signing (this will mean a lot to the starter of the petition).

Thanks for adding your voice.

Suzanne Maltezos
8 years ago
I am not fat, I HAVE fat. I am a woman. I believe that using weight to define health is inaccurate, unscientific prejudice.

Thanks for adding your voice.

Helen Worrall
8 years ago
The AMA's own committee recommended against defining obesity as a disease. I stand with well researched medical scientists in objecting to this decision.

Thanks for adding your voice.

Erica Burden
8 years ago
Our last protected realm of hatred centering around weight is not backed up by real science, and this needs to stop.

Thanks for adding your voice.

Tracy Hayes
8 years ago
The majority of fat people are neither lazy nor gluttonous. We lead busy lives and try to engage in healthful activities and eat healthful foods. We have food diaries, track our water and exercise...but that's often not enough. Many of us have other metabolic and endocrine system issues which complicate our efforts to reduce our masses, such as polycystic ovary syndrome, or hypothyroidism. Many of us have mental health issues, such as post traumatic stress disorder, bipolar disorder, depression, dysthymia, etc. Sometimes we have to take medications that make us feel ravenous and we eat more. Some of us have addictions to foods, because fats and sugars make us have pleasurable feelings, or make us feel less anxious, less depressed, less sad, etc., at least for a little bit. We're not bad people. We're not gross people. We're not stupid people. We are people and we deserve to be treated with the same dignity and respect as all other human beings. Calling 'obesity' a disease is ridiculous as defining alcoholism as a disease. Addiction is a symptom of an underlying mental health and physical health complication. Obesity is a possible outcome of many complicating health factors and each person's journey into obesity is unique. It's not as simple as eat less, exercise more. If it were that easy, we'd all be thin. Learn to actually diagnose and heal others, if you've chosen to work in the medical profession. Don't just simply give a personal observation, weighted with bias, without finding out the facts.

Thanks for adding your voice.

Carolyn Johnson
8 years ago
Because Obesity can be caused by MANY factors. Eating disorders, Trauma, etc...More care needs to happen to help people who have weight issues. More education. Less Body Shaming.

Thanks for adding your voice.

Robin Burns
8 years ago
Obesity isn't a disease in and of itself. It may be a symptom of underlying disease, and can be the effect of unhealthy lifestyles, but it cannot be defined as a disease! To continue treating it as one bypasses more serious approaches that should come first.

Thanks for adding your voice.

Kristy Mounsey
8 years ago
I am not diseased I am big but my body is healthy.

Thanks for adding your voice.

Anita Kanitz
8 years ago
Do images of superthin supermodels play a role in eating disorders?

Eating disorders are responsible for the highest number of deaths from psychiatric illness. The Eating Disorders Association estimates that about 165,000 people in the UK have eating disorders with 10% dying as a result, but experts believe it could be higher. Most sufferers are women, but one in 10 are now men.

The most common eating disorders are anorexia, bulimia and compulsive over-eating. But other disorders exist. For example, some people severely restrict the range of food they eat or several children have a psychological fear of food.

Anorexia, which involves depriving the body of food, is more common in young people. Children as young as three have been treated for it.

Bulimia, characterised by a cycle of starving and bingeing, is more likely in adults.

The emphasis on super-thin models has been blamed for the increase in eating disorders.

Experts say that these can have an effect on how people perceive themselves, but the causes of eating disorders are usually more complex and are linked to general feelings of self-worth.

Anorexia nervosa

Around 5% of young girls in the UK are estimated to have anorexia nervosa. Boys and children from ethnic minorities are much less likely to be affected.

The condition results in death in 20% of cases after 20 years of onset of the illness.

Only around 60% of anorexics recover. The illness is also one of the most controversial areas in mental health.

Psychiatrists have singled out several characteristics which they say are typical of anorexics.

These include: a dominant, over-protective and critical mother and a passive or withdrawn father and a tendency to perfectionism, a strong desire for social approval and a need for order and control.

However, many of these characteristics have been the subject of dispute.

The media and its emphasis on super-thin models is also blamed by some for influencing the way people, particularly girls, see themselves and making them believe looks are all-important.

Feminists argue that it is not the images in themselves which are harmful, but the fact that women still derive much of their sense of self-worth from whether they please men.

Anorexia nervosa is a form of intentional self-starvation. What may begin as a normal diet is carried to extremes, with many reducing their intake to an absolute minimum. It is also characterised by obsessive behaviour. The majority of anorexics deny they have a problem.

Lack of food deprives the body of protein and prevents the normal metabolism of fat. The effects of this can include:

an irregular heart beat caused by a change in the heart muscle. This can lead to heart failure and death.
ceasing of menstruation
dehydration, kidney stones and kidney failure
the growth of fine downy body hair, called lanugo, on the face and arms
wasting away of muscles, leading to weakness
constipation or bowel irritation
osteoporosis caused by lack of calcium.

Symptoms of anorexia

Symptoms of anorexia range from extreme weight loss for no discernable medical reason; ritualistic food habits, such as excessive chewing; denying hunger and exercising excessively to choosing low calorie food and hiding feelings. A person with anorexia may be excessively thin but still see themselves as overweight.

The average age for onset of the illness is thought to be 16, although the age range of anorexia is between 10 and 40. Around 90% of cases are female. Most have no history of being overweight.

Treatment for anorexia

Over 25% of anorexics are so weak that they require hospitalisation. This may involve force feeding as well as advice on healthy eating and counselling.

Many doctors believe that once a person's bodyweight has fallen below a certain level, they are no longer capable of making rational decisions.

There has been wide-ranging debate over whether anorexics should be force-fed or whether they have the right to literally starve themselves to death.

In 1997, guidance was offered to doctors, telling them that they can force feed anorexics over the age of 18 under the Mental Health Act 1983. The anorexic must be shown to be incapable of making rational decisions about their condition.

Other forms of treatment range from group therapy, family counselling and psychotherapy to antidepressants.

Around one third of patients recover fully; another third improve significantly and the last third do not recover.

Bulimia nervosa

Bulimia is thought to be two to three times more common than anorexia, but is not generally as physically dangerous.

However, excessive use of laxatives and self-induced vomiting can cause rupture of the oesophagus, mineral deficiency and dehydration, which can have serious effects on health.

Bulimia was only officially recognised in the 1970s and is characterised by a cycle of bingeing and starving.

Many bulimics seem fine, but experts say that, under the surface, they often feel worthless.

Bulimics may have irregular periods or stop having periods at all because of excessive use of laxatives and vomiting.

Using laxatives can also cause kidney and bowel problems and stomach disorders.

Laxatives do not cause people to lose weight, but remove water and essential minerals, such as potassium, from the body, giving the appearance of weight loss.

Excessive vomiting can cause tooth decay, bad breath, mouth ulcers, sore throats and stomach disorders and may have serious long-term health implications.

Some experts believe bulimia is the result of an imbalance of chemicals to the brain, but others think the illness is more likely to be linked to a lack of self-worth.

It is thought that up to half of anorexics also suffer from bulimia and some 40% of bulimics are reported to have a history of anorexia.

Sufferers tend to be older than anorexics, take a longer time to recover and are more likely ot commit suicide.

Treatment for bulimia includes the use of drugs such as antidepressants, counselling which examines the cause of bulimic behaviour and behavioural modification, including education about healthy eating.

Power Control and obedience

In her book Unbearable Weight, Susan Bordo (1993) makes the argument that the fear of women's fat is actually a fear of women's power. Thus, as women gain power in society, their bodies dwindle and suffer. She states that "female hunger--for public power, for independence, for sexual gratification-- [must] be contained, and the public space that women be allowed to take up be circumscribed, limited... On the body of the anorexic woman such rules are grimly and deeply etched" (Bordo, 171).

Naomi Wolf (1991) has a similar explanation of the origin of eating disorders in her bestseller The Beauty Myth. She states: "a cultural fixation on female thinness is not an obsession.

Topless feminists from the feminist group Femen protested against use of the anorexic models outside the Versace fashion show in Milan in 2012. Topless feminists tried to enter into Versace Fall-winter 2012-2013 show during the Milan Womenswear Fashion Week having a handwritten slogan such as ‘Fashion = Fascism’ and ‘Anorexia’ illegible
across their bare bodies. But Italian police prevented them from entering the Versace fashion show.

Allegra, the daughter of Donatella Versace and successor to the fashion throne battling anorexia for years.Femen group battling against sex tourists, international marriage agencies, sexism and other social, national and international ills.

Feminists have claimed that 150,000 women DIE each year because of anorexia.

Feminists have identified women’s bodies as the locus of patriarchal control and power, for example in the medicalisation of reproduction and reproductive rights, physical and sexual abuse, in the sexualisation of the female body and the ‘beauty’ standards which women strive to achieve. Discuss how this process of objectification of the body may or may not work to weaken the position of women in society (Robin Grace).

Another problem is that the illness causes a huge shift in the way in which we perceive the size and shape of our bodies, meaning that the little bit of weightloss is never, ever enough – those thighs are always too chubby, the stomach too rotund, the arms too wobbly and the cheekbones invisible, hidden beneath a cushion of podgy fat. You engage in a behaviour to control the way you looks – and in the case of plastic surgery, although people do get addicted and spend thousands on repeated procedures (many suffering from the same Body Dysmorphia as Anorexia and Bulimia sufferers), there is at least a degree of control and safety. There are protocols, rules and restraints, there are people to make the changes to you, for you, to look after you and make sure that everything goes perfectly. Eating Disorders are solitary – your actions, your choices, your illness and nobody interferes with that. In terms of dramatically changing ones appearance, being Anorexic or Bulimic – risking health and even life to alter the shape of the human body – would come close to extreme surgery only if the person were to perform the surgery themselves.

Thanks for adding your voice.

Amanda Mullins
8 years ago
You better believe I'm signing this. I am NOT a disease!

Thanks for adding your voice.

Rachel Moore
8 years ago
Weight /= health.