A talent show should be about talent. Icky Minaj does not posess the necessary qualities to judge a musical talent show. She is trying to make the show about her, and taking the spotlight off of the contestants. How about a replacing her with a judge who is an accomplished musician; one who can play an instrument, compose meaningful lyrics, and has been successful for more than 14 minutes. Perhaps one who doesn't constantly disrespect more experiened singers due to insecurity and jealousy, as Icky Nicky has done to Mariah Carey. This is a huge turn off, and I will tune out if Nicky is still on the show when the live shows begin.
- American Idol Producers
fire icky Nicky Minaj
Lisa Shaat started this petition with a single signature, and now has 12 supporters. Start a petition today to change something you care about.