Watchdog says Sainsbury’s ‘Fairly Traded’ tea is misleading
Mar 8, 2018 — The advertising standards agency (ASA) is on our side! The watchdog has just declared that Sainsbury’s ‘Fairly Traded’ tea is likely to confuse shoppers into thinking it is Fairtrade certified.
The ruling comes after Stella Creasy MP, a supporter of the Don’t Ditch Fairtrade campaign, complained to the ASA that Sainsbury’s new ‘Fairly Traded’ logo was misleading customers. They said: ‘We considered the fact that their own-brand products using two different fair trade schemes was likely to cause confusion for consumers, who might assume that the packaging was using ‘Fairly Traded’ as a descriptive term to convey that it was part of the official Fairtrade scheme, rather than that ‘Fairly Traded’ was itself the name of a separate scheme run by Sainsbury’s.’
You can read more about the ruling here: https://ind.pn/2FnXjBL
It’s a great to see that an official watchdog like the ASA agrees with what we’ve been saying from the very beginning: Sainsbury’s ‘Fairly Traded’ tea is confusing and misleading to customers, who are likely to think it is the same as independent and transparent, farmer-owned Fairtrade certification. And it’s not.
Meeting with Sainsbury’s
I also wanted to update you on the meeting I had with Sainsbury’s on 18th December. I went with representatives from the Don't Ditch Fairtrade campaign (www.dontditchfairtrade.com) and on behalf of all of you who signed this petition. We met with Judith Batchelar, Director of Sainsbury’s Brand, and senior members of her team, and had a positive discussion.
We gave them the very strong message that supporters don't like the proposed use of the social premium and don't like the use of the words 'fairly traded' on their own brand tea. Every rationale they gave for their new scheme was countered with the argument that it could, and should, be done within the Fairtrade Mark. They listened to our concerns and it was good to note their professed concern for workers' rights.
Your voices and those of tea farmers and workers worldwide were heard by the highest level of Sainsbury's management. This was another step in the campaign and thank you all for your support so far.
The Fairtrade Foundation have told me that they’re still in conversation with Sainsbury’s about their tea, as well as their roll out of ‘Fairly Traded’ to other products. Hence the pause in the campaign. I’m hopeful, as I’m sure you are too, that we will soon have a renewed commitment from Sainsbury’s to Fairtrade.
In the meantime, please share the important news about the ASA’s ruling with your fellow Fairtrade supporters.
Happy Fairtrade Fortnight!