Medical Staff, Community Physicians, Residents and Alumni
Started 1 petition
Support for UBCHO faculty!
The affiliation between Children's Hospital Oakland and UCSF in 2014 promised to combine world class institutions to create new clinical, research and educational programs and extend our mission in child health. However, the reorganization between the two institutions has resulted in a two tiered academic and clinical operation, in which the current UCSF faculty assumes all leadership and controls all management decisions. Please support the Oakland faculty as they propose universal principles which will lead to a fair and equal leadership structure! Attached is the faculty letter submitted to the Board, along with a statement of support from community physicians: Dear Dr. Hawgood and Members of the Board of Directors: The UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital Oakland (Oakland) faculty is committed to an academic affiliation with UCSF School of Medicine, establishing an affiliated faculty at Oakland and SF hospitals with a common mission, and embracing a renewed vision of excellence in child health. Children’s Hospital Oakland has a 100 year history of providing high level specialty and trauma services and community centered care for the East Bay and Northern California community at large. The affiliation agreement in January 2014 promised to combine world class institutions to create new clinical, research and educational programs and extend our mission in child health. The Oakland faculty has presented several models of reorganization for the combined UCSF enterprise. These have all been dismissed by UCSF. Instead, an organizational hierarchy was presented by UCSF administrative leadership, which will create a two tiered academic and clinical operation, in which the current UCSF faculty assumes all leadership and controls all management decisions. The Oakland faculty formally declares that it has no confidence in the proposed integration plan and its unequal leadership structure. In response, we have drafted universal principles to guide integration of all the affected medical and surgical facultydivisions in Oakland: 1. Faculty in Oakland will be included in strategic planning of the affiliation withtransparency about the details to ensure a successful outcome. 2. As this is an affiliation, and not a merger, an acquisition or a take-over, selection of clinical and academic leadership positions will be based upon merit (qualification and experience), rather than the arbitrary selection of current UCSF faculty for all leadership positions. Selections should not be determined by geography alone, and should be conducted with guidance from current leaders and faculty at both SF and Oakland sites. An acceptable outcome would be a parallel and autonomous structure of governance in Oakland. 3. Integration activities must be conducted with respectful interactions and culturalsensitivity. 4. We expect that clinical, translational and basic science research activities in Oakland will not be diminished after integration. As per the initial affiliation agreement, research activities at all levels, commitment to education and training, and programmatic development will be expanded after academic integration in a joint endeavor across both the SF and Oakland sites. We endorse retaining CHORI laboratory operations in close proximity to the hospital because these are vital to current and future translational and clinical research activities in the hospital. 5. We are concerned the present integration plan may result in decreased health equity for our patient population and increased health disparity. We believe that these basic tenets underlying the affiliation are fair and reasonable, are not controversial, and should be embraced and implemented immediately. We invite the Board of Directors and Dr. Hawgood to meet with the Oakland Medical Staff to discuss the obstacles and our solutions. Respectfully submitted by the UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital Oakland medical staff departments of: Adolescent MedicineAnesthesiaCardiologyCenter for Child ProtectionCenter for Community Health and EngagementDermatologyDiagnostic ImagingEmergency DepartmentEndocrinologyGastroenterologyGraduate Medical EducationHematology/Oncology/Bone Marrow TransplantHospitalistsInfectious DiseasesNeonatologyNeurologyNeurosurgeryPathologyPediatric Critical CarePediatric SurgeryPrimary CareRehabilitation Community Physician Response: We, the community physicians on the medical staff of UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital Oakland, would like to add our support to the sentiments expressed in the letter to the Board of Directors from the faculty of UBCHO dated March 6, 2018. We are equally concerned about the disparities in the care that our patients may receive due to the inability of the medical staff at UBCHO to have an equal voice in the decisions made regarding programs and resources. Without this voice, it seems likely that many of the services required to fulfill our mission to protect and advance the health and well-being of children through clinical care, teaching and research will be threatened. We ask that the voices of the Medical Staff leadership at both UCSF Benioff Children’s Hospital campuses are given parity. It is our belief that we will only be able to achieve the shared mission of our organization with this combined and balanced approach.