The Hartford: Stop Harassing/Retaliating Against Accident Victims & Delaying Payment
  • Petitioning Chris Chase

This petition will be delivered to:

Western Regional Manager
Chris Chase
Law Dept/Corporate Ethics
Thomas Jones
Consumer Affairs
Meggan K. Conner
Law Dept
Robin Najduch
Law Dept
Melissa Giard
Adjuster
Erin Trimmer
Adjuster's Supervisor
Karin Stoner
Media Relations
Media Relations
AARP
Denise Henderson
Washington State Office of Insurance Commissioner
Insurance Commissioner
President & CEO
Liam McGee
Washington Governor
President of the United States
Washington State Senate
Washington State House
U.S. Senate
U.S. House of Representatives

The Hartford: Stop Harassing/Retaliating Against Accident Victims & Delaying Payment

    1. Carol Tucker
    2. Petition by

      Carol Tucker

      Ocean Shores, WA

On October 17th, 2012, while making a left turn, my car was rear-ended by a clearly distracted, speeding driver of a large pick-up truck, who hit me so hard my knees slammed into the dashboard,my car spun around, and by the time it stopped, I was facing the opposite direction. I heard the rear windshield shatter, metal twisting, and saw pieces of my car careen across the road. The driver's seat partially dislodged and reclined to a 45-degree angle. My beloved little blue 1999 Suzuki Esteem, which had a great deal of sentimental value, was destroyed. The man who hit me came over to me and inappropriately started accusing me of not having my blinker on, which was untrue. When the EMTs came, my blood pressure was 200/100. I am low-income, on Social Security, food stamps, and housing vouchers to survive, and now my only form of transportation is destroyed. It is common knowledge that Japanese engines last 200,000-300,000 miles and my Suzuki had about 140,000 miles and would have probably lasted me the rest of my life.

As many people are already aware who have had auto accidents, the insurance industry spends billions on tasteless advertising campaigns, but when we have accidents and need our claims paid timely, need insurance companies who have gladly collected our premiums to make good on their contractual obligations, they suddenly turn from Jekyll to Hyde.

I am insured with AARP-The Hartford for auto insurance and have been for many years. The at-fault driver is insured with Progressive. Both insurance companies treated me from the minute I first filed the claim, like something on the bottom of their shoes.

Their first manipulative tactic is try to get accident victims to only speak to them verbally on the phone or in person. NEVER DO THIS. Insist on e-mail communication, and if they refuse, immediately file complaints with your state's Office of Insurance Commissioner, which I did, as a resident of Washington State, and from then on, of course, the acts of retaliation began and not only still continue, but have grossly escalated.

Even though Japanese engines are of such proven longevity, neither Hartford nor Progressive would offer me more than a mere pittance for my vehicle, and because I am low-income, I cannot afford car payments, nor can I be approved for a car loan without a huge down payment. The Hartford stopped paying for the rental vehicle, so I am now without transportation to medical appointments, pharmacies, grocery shopping, etc.

The Hartford is contractually obligated to reimburse me for "essential services," such as taxi fares and house cleaning assistance, which I can't afford to pay upfront, and Hartford refuses to pay out the $5,000 in essential services I'm entitled to upfront--which they could do if they wanted--knowing full well that I'm low-income on Social Security, but they stubbornly refuse.

As far as personal injury attorneys are concerned, my experience with them has been just as bad or worse as with the insurance companies themselves. Many of you may or may not know that what personal injury attorneys basically do is negotiate "sweetheart deals" with the insurance companies, negotiating one case against another--and who loses--the accident victim/client that gets the short end of the stick, plus the fact that the personal injury attorneys I've ever been involved with are rude, disrespectful, dishonest, and verbally abusive, both to their clients and their staff, which I've witnessed for myself.

Therefore, though I'm injured, in pain, and without transportation (and I cannot utilize public transportation without risk of infection, as I have hypogammaglobulinemia, which is low Ig levels--immunoglobulin--for which I'm currently not receiving infusion--a condition which puts sufferers at high risk of infection and is aggravated by stress, such as the stress of this accident, plus the unnecessary stress caused me by both Hartford and Progressive), as I cannot even bend over to tie my shoes without pain, still both insurance companies, particularly The Hartford at this point, continue to retaliate against me by refusing to pay my claims and dysfunctionally try to force me to only communicate with one (weird, creepy) person there, which I will not agree to, nor should anyone else, should you ever be coerced by an insurane company to do so.

And another manipulative tactic insurance companies try to get away with is by trying to convince victims that the PIP is supposed to be reimbursed to them out of the other company's Bodily Injury. THIS IS COMPLETELY UNTRUE! The Bodily Injury is NOT a bank account for the insurance companies to pay themselves back out of, and they collude with each other to try to make this happen.The PIP and the Bodily Injury are for the injured party's medical bills and pain and suffering, and since my medical bills have already maxed the PIP, and I have proven repeatedly to Progressive that the Bodily Injury will be--and is already in the process of being--repleted, as well, that Hartford is justified in paying out my $25,000 UM, but they won't even pay out my eseential services, and continue to threaten, inappropriately accuse me, and try to silence me, which "ain't gonna happen."

What Hartford doesn't seem to get--not now, nor five years ago--is how to diffuse a situation rather than further inflame it--but by having Meggan Conner send me a threatening letter, and by having Chris Chase, creepily try to convince me to only communicate with him, that's exactly what they're doing--deliberately throwing oil on the fire, which is low-mentality, lazy thinking, completely bereft of communication skills, negoatiating skills, diplomacy, as well as completely bereft of human compassion.

Once I filed OIC complaints, both Hartford and Progressive began communicating with me via e-mail, but in an uncooperative, vindictive, and retaliatory manner. I complained to both their corporate offices, who only further retaliated by deliberately slowing down the processing of my claims to a snail's pace, inappropriately ordering the adjusters to not communicate with me, so the corporate offices could deliberately slow down the handling of my claim.

Chris Chase has taken this abuse to a whole new level. He keeps sending me e-mails--like he's the boss of me or something--ordering me to only communicate with him--which is very creepy, dysfunctional, extremely inappropriate, and downright abusive. He went on Thanksgiving vacation, ordered no one else at Hartford to respond to me or pay out anything to me, and then when he returned, he lied in an e-mail and claimed he'd only been out one day. Every time these incidents happen, I immediately inform OIC, but Hartford continues to treat me worse and worse, and now, one of their Consumer Affairs employees, Meggan Conner, wrote me a threatening, abusive letter, accusing ME of being abusive (that's their standard modus operandi--lamely accuse the victim of being abusive to draw attention away from their OWN abusive and retaliatory behavior).

I may be low-income, and rely on Social Security, food stamps, and housing vouchers to survive, but I will NOT remain silent and be dictated to by an insurance company, to whom I can and cannot communicate with, and I have e-mailed Hartford repeatedly, informing them in no uncertain terms that I will not accept this behavior or continue to be treated like a doormat by them.

Not only that, but I recently learned that Hartford has been scamming policy holders with regard to Underinsured Motorists insurance. They falsely claimed I have $10,000 in UM, when in actuality, I have $25,000, which of course they refuse to pay out, in spite of the fact that I desperately need it. This also means that five years ago when I lived in Florida, Hartford cheated me out of $15,000 UM following an auto accident that left me homeless, living in a motel for nine months while fighting with the insurance companies involved at that time (GEICO and Hartford) for my benefits.

Now, five years later, the very same thing is happening, which clearly indicates, as many of you are aware, that the insurance industry in this country has been and continues to get away with murder. Instead of spending billions of dollars on tasteless advertising, they should be spending that money on their policy holders, but instead they pay their CEOs obscenely large salaries, which attests to their arrogance and lack of concern and compassion for the health and welfare of their customers. THIS MUST STOP.

The insurance industry is actually the guilty party at fault for the demise of the middle class in this country, as they continue to gouge American companies more and more for group health and worker's comp premiums, to the point where companies/corporations (rather than stand up to the insurance industry themselves), sent American jobs overseas (which never should have been legal to begin with), but nevertheless, the result is the same--the destruction of the middle class--and STILL--no one stands up to the insurance industry because they continue to bribe politicians in the form of campaign contributions (which should also be illegal, as should superpacs), so it is up to us--people like you and me who have been repeatedly and unjustly abused by insurance companies--to speak out about this and insist on change and accountability. (And if we had universal healthcare in this country, this would not have happened...but WHO benefits from private and group health insurance and worker's comp insurance--the insurance industry and no one else).

I am asking all of you to help me in this endeavor by e-mailing the President and legislators at both State and Federal levels, insisting on massive insurance industry reform, and to please help me receive my benefits so I can survive, by e-mailing The Hartford staff, and insist they immediately cease and desist from dysfunctionally and creepily insisting I communicate solely with Chris Chase, insist the adjuster, Erin Trimmer and her supervisor, Karin Stoner, communicate with me directly and immediately pay out my essential services and UM, immediately insist Meggan Conner cease and desist from sending me threatening letters and ordering me to communicate only with her (regarding the fact that Hartford tried to get me to continue paying monthly premiums for a vehicle I no longer have, threatening to charge me higher fees at some future date when I procure another vehicle), immediately pay out my $5,000 in essential services so I have money for taxi fares and house cleaning services ordered by my physician, immediately pay out my $25,000 in UM, and pay out the $15,000 in UM they cheated me out of in 2007.

I am injured and in pain and without transportation, as a direct result of being treated abusively by the insurance companies, particularly The Hartford. I have complained to OIC and AARP, to no avail. I have a torn meniscus which may require surgery, and I cannot stand or walk for very long without pain. I have asthma and a weakened immune system, all of which are exacerbated by the unnecessary stress heaped upon me by The Hartford and Progressive.

It's time for us to stand up to the insurance industry and insist on strong legislation protecting consumers instead of the insurance industry, as well as strong, prompt enforcement and penalties.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

01-31-2013 ADDENDUM TO ABOVE PETITION AND LETTER:

ERIN TRIMMER, ONE OF MY ADJUSTERS CONFIRMED TO ME THAT CHRIS CHASE, WESTERN REGIONAL MANAGER, HAS DELIBERATELY ORDERED HARTFORD'S WEBMASTER TO ENSURE THAT ALL E-MAILS ADDRESSED TO ANYONE AT THE HARTFORD OTHER THAN HIM ARE AUTOMATICALLY FORWARDED TO HIM, SO MY ADJUSTERS NEVER SEE THEM, THEN HE HAS DELIBERATELY BEEN REFUSING TO PROVIDE MY ADJUSTERS WITH MY TRANSPORTATION ESSENTIAL SERVICES RECEIPTS, TO DELIBERATELY DELAY REIMBURSEMENT.

TO MAKE MATTERS WORSE, HE E-MAILED ME THIS CLOWNISH UNDERINSURED MOTORISTS RELEASE, WHICH CLEARLY, IS NOT A "NORMAL" RELEASE, AND ONE HE CONCOCTED TO TRY TO TRICK ME INTO SIGNING AWAY MY RIGHTS TO CONTINUE TO BE REIMBURSED FOR TRANSPORTATION ESSENTIAL SERVICES HERE IS THE RELEASE, COPIED & PASTED BELOW:

RELEASE AGREEMENT

TO ALL WHOM THESE PRESENTS SHALL COME OR MAY CONCERN: KNOW YE, THAT I Carol Tucker ("Releasor")
in consideration of the sum of TWENTY-FIVE THOUSAND $25,000.00, to me in hand paid by Hartford Casualty
Insurance Company and its affiliates (hereinafter referred to as "Hartford"), the receipt of which is hereby acknowledged,
do for myself, my heirs, executors, administrators, legal representatives, successors and assigns, hereby remise, release
and forever discharge Hartford, its successors, assigns and legal representatives, of and from all debts, dues, sums of
money, obligations, reckoning, promises, covenants, agreements, contracts, endorsements, bonds, specialties,
controversies, suits, actions, causes of action, trespasses, variances, judgments, executions, damages, claims or
demands in law or in equity which against The Hartford I ever had, or now have or in the future may have, without
limitation, arising out of or pertaining to UNDERINSURED motorist coverage provided under an automobile insurance
policy, bearing policy number 55 PHL 439035 issued by Hartford to Carol Tucker and resulting from an accident which
occurred on 10/17/2012 in Woodinville , WA.

I do hereby agree to reimburse, indemnify and save harmless Hartford against any further claims under said policy
resulting from the above accident.

I do further covenant and represent that I fully understand the terms of the settlement and have executed this Release
knowing the binding legal effect thereof.

    IN WITNESS THEREOF, l/we have signed our signatures this      day of         ,     .


                                                       
  Releasor Name                   Address                   Signature

                                                       
  Releasor Name                   Address                   Signature

                                                       
  Witness Name                   Address                   Signature

                                                       
  Witness Name                   Address                   Signature


STATE OF                
                         ss.
COUNTY OF                

Sworn and subscribed to before me by the above named person(s) who personally appeared before me this          date
of         , 20    , and who acknowledged that he/she/they signed the instrument freely and voluntarily.


                   
Notary Public

For your protection, Washington law requires the following statement to appear on this form.

"It is a crime to knowingly provide false, incomplete, or misleading information to an insurance company for the
purpose of defrauding the company. Penalties include imprisonment, fines, and denial of insurance benefits."

Handling ID:
LTR8513909
N9L

HIGC-C05300-PA0010946351-YKQ AU 63578
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
IS THIS NOT THE MOST RIDICULOUS RELEASE ANY OF YOU HAVE EVER SEEN? WHAT GIVES AARP-THE HARTFORD OR ANY OTHER INSURANCE CORPORATION THE RIGHT TO BULLY AND HARASS A FEMALE, DISABLED CAR ACCIDENT VICTIM? APPARENTLY HARTFORD'S ARROGANCE AND CORPORATE THUGGERY ARE ROOTED IN THE CAMPAIGN CONTRIBUTIONS, I.E., BRIBERY, OF POLITICIANS SUCH AS MIKE KREIDLER, WASHINGTON STATE INSURANCE COMMISSIONER, FOR HIS OFFICE HAS DONE ABSOLUTELY NOTHING TO STOP THE HARTFORD'S ABUSIVE BEHAVIOR, AND INAPPROPRIATE ORDERING OF MY ADJUSTERS, ERIN TRIMMER AND NANCY LAPORTE TO NOT COMMUNICATE WITH ME. IN FACT, MARY CHILDERS WITH MIKE KREIDLER'S OFFICE WROTE ME A THREATENING E-MAIL, THREATENING TO HAVE ME ARRESTED (REALLY! SERIOUSLY!) IF I CONTINUE TO CONTACT THEIR OFFICE, FALSELY ACCUSING ME OF BEING ABUSIVE, WHICH IS COMPLETELY UNTRUE, AND I HAVE COPIES OF ALL COMMUNICATIONS I HAVE MADE TO WAOIC.. WOW! WHEN DID WE BECOME THAT NATION? A NATION WHOSE GOVERNMENT AGENCIES WITH EMPLOYEES PAID TO PROTECT OUR COUNTRY'S MOST VULNERABLE CITIZENS SUCH AS MYSELF, INSTEAD, THREATEN US?? WHAT'S UP WITH THAT??

THIS PETITION TARGETS STATE AND FEDERAL ELECTED OFFICIALS, SO WHICH OF YOU WILL STEP UP TO THE PLATE AND DO SOMETHING ABOUT THE MANNER IN WHICH INSURANCE CORPORATIONS AND STATE INSURANCE COMMISSIONERS TREAT ACCIDENT VICTIMS. IT'S BAD ENOUGH TO BE ALMOST KILLED AND REAR-ENDED BY A DISTRACTED TRUCK DRIVER TO BEGIN WITH, BUT THEN TO BE VICTIMIZED A SECOND TIME BY THE INSURANCE COMPANIES, AND A THIRD TIME BY THE WASHINGTON STATE INSURANCE COMMISSIONER, MIKE KREIDLER, IS UNCONSCIONABLE.

Recent signatures

    News

    1. Reached 50 signatures

    Supporters

    Reasons for signing

    • Diana Erickson LINCOLN, NE
      • about 1 month ago

      I am going through the same thing.right now. Suffering with the pain and misery of an auto accident that was not my fault and being pressured by a insurance adjuster and a injury attorney. I am borderline homeless because of all of it. I am the victim here.And will get nothing in the end. I am now permanently disabled for life.

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:
    • ZILKA DAMIEN AIX-EN-PROVENCE, FRANCE
      • about 1 year ago

      yes !!!!!

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:
    • Mary Ciulla ROCHESTER, NY
      • over 1 year ago

      I've paid a great deal of money for insurance coverage over the years, and I would not want to be treated this way in the event of an accident.

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:
    • Pamela Harris SEATAC, WA
      • over 1 year ago

      yikes!!! I have Hartford too!

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:
    • shari ward TAMPA, FL
      • over 1 year ago

      If we don't stand up for our rights the insurance companies will walk all over us and try to deny us benefits that are due to us. The insurance companies don't care about the insured person, it is all about making money.

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:

    Develop your own tools to win.

    Use the Change.org API to develop your own organizing tools. Find out how to get started.