MTA NYC: Install platform doors at dangerous NYC Subway Stations
  • Petitioned Tom Predergast

This petition was delivered to:

MTA New York City Transit President
Tom Predergast

MTA NYC: Install platform doors at dangerous NYC Subway Stations

    1. Ed David
    2. Petition by

      Ed David

      Brooklyn, NY

Dear MTA:

On Friday, March 24, 2012, Joshua Basin was pushed and pulled into the tracks of the Bedford Avenue L train station.   He was pinned and killed by an incoming train.  

In Decemeber, two seperate incidents of men were pushed onto the tracks, igniting incredible disgust as a photographer filmed the first man as he lay there, trying to escape from a train.  A gruesome scenerio that affects the mental health of our city.

Platform screen doors would have prevented this death amongst many more deaths that happen every year in the NYC MTA stations.

It's time to install platform doors in some of New York City's most dangerous subway stations.  It's time for NYC to get up to speed with other global cities.

Platform screen doors are used in France, India, Japan, many European nations and Chicago. 

In addition to keeping the subway safer, they speed up commute time and keep the subway cleaner.  But as I mentioned earlier, the fear of death that enters people's minds as they walk past dangerous areas such as the 14th street union square passageway from the N, R, Q train to the L train can add to overall mental health issues, something that is not quantifyable in terms of later cost and condition of the city's residents and visitors.

We need to retrofit existing dangerous train stations with these screen doors, not all of them.  

In the end this expense will save money in terms of faster-moving trains, less debris, less accidents, in addition to saving lives and increasing the mental health of New York.  If costs can be kept down via creative ideas such as offsetting the cost with advertising, this would be an excellent addition to the Subway.

**UPDATE 2:**

Great article looking at the issue from the Associated Press:


Interesting thread on this subject including MTA support for platform doors:



Recent signatures


    1. Reached 100 signatures


    Reasons for signing

    • Rathna Chaudhry NEW YORK, NY
      • 9 months ago

      I commute to Manhattan every work day and it maes me sad every tie I hear an accident or alleged pushing on people onto tracks. It's time the city makes changes such that accidents are prevented and people are rescued.

    • Kelly Wu NY, NY
      • 12 months ago

      Life is priceless.

    • Terrence Davis BRONX, NY
      • about 1 year ago

      I ride the subway often, and a lot of people have been killed because of this.

    • Kyle Burger MORRISVILLE, PA
      • about 1 year ago

      I live in Seoul, Korea and all of the subways here have it! Its just a normal thing and it drastically cuts down on accidents. Plus, they still manage to charge the equivalent of $1 USD per ride on the Seoul subway. Safety isn't an option, you must begin installation on stations if you want people to be safer.

    • maria okeeffe CARTERET, NJ
      • about 1 year ago

      My daughters regularly use NYC subways.


    Develop your own tools to win.

    Use the API to develop your own organizing tools. Find out how to get started.