Veterans Affairs: Support a 90 yr old Purple Heart recipient and veteran of two wars
  • Petitioning Kathleen Fogarty
  • Responded

This petition will be delivered to:

Director, James A. Haley Veterans’ Hospital
Kathleen Fogarty
See response
Deputy Director, James A. Haley Veterans’ Hospital
Roy L. Hawkins Jr.
Chief of Staff, James A. Haley Veterans’ Hospital
Dr. Edward P. Cutolo Jr.
Secretary of Veterans Affairs
Honorable Eric K. Shinseki
Hillsborough County Aging Services Division- Executive Director
Bart Banks
Florida-14
Rep. Kathy Castor
Florida
Sen. Bill Nelson
Florida
Sen. Marco Rubio

Veterans Affairs: Support a 90 yr old Purple Heart recipient and veteran of two wars

    1. Nicole March
    2. Petition by

      Nicole March

      Sun City Center, FL

My dad, James March, is a World War II and Korean War veteran with a Purple Heart he received in WW2 -- but now that he's seriously ill, the VA is refusing to help him. 

Even though his injury from the war caused him terrible back and leg pain throughout his life, my dad never complained to the VA -- he rarely asks for help from anyone. But now that he's 90 years old, dad is really sick and he urgently needs help from an assisted living facility. Our whole family is worried about him: he's barely eating, he's nearly lost his eyesight, and he's suffering from dementia. In just a few months, he lost 70 pounds. 

Dad needs constant care, but Mom isn't able to be a full-time caregiver because she's struggling with cancer recovery and diabetes -- and my family doesn't have enough money to pay out of pocket for him to get a home aide.

The VA lost our application for assistance two times before they denied our claim. Even though my parents are crippled by medical costs and their home  was foreclosed on 2/27/2013, the VA says my dad "makes too much money" to qualify for help. In reality, my parents barely have enough left over at the end of the month to buy their groceries, let alone pay for at-home care.

My dad was there when our country needed him to fight in WWII, healing others as a medic on the battlefield where he earned a Purple Heart. Now that he needs us, will we turn our back on him? Sign my petition asking that the VA give my dad the benefits he and all veterans deserve for their service and sacrifice.

Recent signatures

    News

    1. it just doesnt end

      Nicole March
      Petition Organiser

      ahh the neverending train of people asking for money after someone dies. My father is by no means rich and it is all piling on my mother.....its just sad. even 9 months later

    2. aftermath....continued

      Nicole March
      Petition Organiser

      Now unfortunately dealing with a large amount of things my father didnt deal with in his last functioning year. This truly sucks...didnt think it would be going on this long. I feel quite sad for my mother his widow. She gets the burnt of it

    3. hi again

      Nicole March
      Petition Organiser

      still looking at this page. We are still actually dealing with the aftereffect of the insurances and all that jazz and what you do after someone has died. Once thats settled I may see what is available to my mother if anything, from the VA

    4. Reached 100,000 signatures
    5. just ridiculous

      Nicole March
      Petition Organiser

      just had some more DISGUSTING treatment from the VA from a phone call received this week. They didnt even know he was dead. You would not believe how they referred to him

    6. thanks again

      Nicole March
      Petition Organiser

      for all the continued signatures. Its amazing though we never really got what we wanted. Maybe the more signatures that still come will help the next old guy who needs help.

    7. im free poem for his funeral

      Nicole March
      Petition Organiser

      Don't grieve for me for now I'm free. I'm following the path God laid for me. I took his hand when I heard him call. I turned my back and left it all. I could not stay another day, To laugh, to love, to work, or play. Tasks left undone must stay that way, I've found that peace at the close of day. If my parting has left a void, Then fill it with remembered joy. A friendship shared, a laugh, a kiss,
      Ah yes, these things I too will miss. Be not burdened with times of sorrow:
      I wish you the sunshine of tomorrow. My life's been full I've savored much,
      Good times, good friends, a loved one's touch. Perhaps my time seemed all to brief, Don't lengthen it now with undue grief. Lift up your heart and share with me, God wanted me now, he set me free.
      Author: Unknown

      Northern Lexicon - Your One Stop Translation Agency

      Northern Lexicon is a translation agency formed by a unique collaboration of Translation and Localization professionals from various countries across the globe.

    8. he passed away last night

      Nicole March
      Petition Organiser

      Thank you all for your hope, help, and thank you's, advice, and completely amazing thoughts of care. Last night he passed away at Lakeland hospital. Wake will be Monday in sun city fl, with a mass Tuesday also in sun city. Thank you from your spots around the country and world.

      When this is all over id like to consider continuing this fight as i've been told by many others that my mom is deserving of money. We will see, perhaps this petition will continue. I have no idea if that is true.

      here is the prayer picked out for him today- Id thought id share. It will be in another post

    9. As with his age this wasnt unexpected but he is dying now.

      Nicole March
      Petition Organiser

      But I never expected it to be this way. We never expected the words amputation, or rehab or anything like that again. I didnt think he would need to have the pain of a amputation surgery at his age, or the slow painful infection of letting it go. We expected a call he went in his sleep not this. Unfortunately my dad couldnt have the surgery thursday as he flatlined when it started. He was on life support until yesterday when we had family members come in to see him. he is off it now and still breathing but it will be anytime now. Im exhausted and I wish it didnt have to be this way. I question did the home he was in not take enough of a look at his leg? how did it get in that condition? but thats nothing I guess im going to worry about now. it will all be over soon.

    10. nothing new

      Nicole March
      Petition Organiser

      so we sent away for his medical records and they claim "they need more information" we sent copies of his discharge papers what more do you want?

      we have hit the proverbial wall and are losing hope quick

    11. Sorry I havent updated this week/the gofundme page

      Nicole March
      Petition Organiser

      we have been working hard in phone calls and paperwork and finally met a Veterans Officer who was smart and kind to us and has at least been helping us. But as we are still awaiting medical records and may have to move him AGAIN, nothing technically has progressed. Im not really thrilled about things in general, but it is what it is. I may change or end this petition in the next few weeks. We thank you all again for your signatures, and for your immense kindness for another human being in need.

      As I stated before A friend made a page for us at gofundme. No one has donated and I wasnt expecting people too. But since I had some requests via PM for the link here it is.
      http://www.gofundme.com/2i9g4s

    12. Reached 75,000 signatures
    13. Unsure about this- a friend is trying to persuade me to try donations

      Nicole March
      Petition Organiser

      A friend of mine asked to put a donation page up for me at gofundme. I had no intention of asking for money, but i've had people tell me maybe I should ask for more professional help ie. a lawyer or aging care advocate. It makes me very anxious to have a donation page up it feels bizarre. I wont post the link here but if you want it PM me. I have no issues if no one wants to donate.

    14. radio interview

      Nicole March
      Petition Organiser

      So if you are in the TAMPABAY area I will unless something changes last minute be a phone guest on the cowhead show on 102.5 the bone tomorrow 4/3 at 430pm. Please listen

    15. If true....what would you like

      Nicole March
      Petition Organiser

      I have seen a couple of responses saying If true...

      I completely understand this comment. I know there are nasty people committing fraud. I work in the security arena and its unfortunate that sometimes people will lie. So I want all our bases covered.

      We are not lying.
      we are not looking for a handout we just want help for my dad

      so if anyone wants proof please PM me.

      I will show proof of foreclosed house
      VA denial letter
      medical bills etc
      whatever you wish.

      Just wanted to put that out there that we have proof of our predicament.

      I know some will say this is completely unnecessary but I just want to make sure that if needed this can easily be proved true

      Thank you all again for signing

    16. Foreclosed

      Nicole March
      Petition Organiser

      Though we had moved out earlier due to being unable to stop the foreclosure it appears it was officially sold in courthouse/online foreclosure auction 2/27/2013

    17. Reached 50,000 signatures
    18. Purple heart.

      Nicole March
      Petition Organiser

      Now we have issues with this. I have questions to vets here. His purple heart is not listed on his discharge. Now ive been told this can be amended. (by the way we have the medal itself, my father knows how he got it) has this happened to anyone else? I was told it can be amended with a DD215.

    19. Part 2?

      Nicole March
      Petition Organiser

      to make him eligible? If by chance we are turned down for medicaid are these nursing homes going to take us to court for this money ?? could we be turned down by the VA for something else? My father needs constant care, my mother cant provide it she is not a nurse and neither am I. He has dementia and can be a handle to deal with. Boy can he yell still! Coming home would be a threat to his own safety and possibly my mothers as a caregiver due to his confusion and sickness. So what do we do when the whole option is a giant circle?
      Before this whole VA thing began we spoke with Elder services we were put on waivers that could take a year plus, we were told about medicaid, a self abuse report was filed due to his non eating. THEY recommended the VA.
      I tried to find every option available and to do the "right thing" What are the options left?
      I will take anyone' s recommendations.

      He and we deserve better,

      But now im at a loss for the next step.

    20. What to do? what else is left? this will be in a few parts

      Nicole March
      Petition Organiser

      So I ask the question if no option is left where does he go?

      So I spoke with someone today from a non VA-related but veterans website nonetheless. They were very nice. They explained the denial a bit better to my understanding. He has been denied because we are not paying currently for his specialized nursing care as we await medicaid and were awaiting VA. Now while we are not paying we ARE BEING BILLED. ITS ALOT THOUSANDS. Im guessing because if we are turned down by medicaid THEY WANT THERE MONEY.

      According to this VA affiliate now if he was denied medicaid and we started paying for him privately for a home health nurse or a nursing home we could qualify as that medical expense would deplete our supposed income.

      But the question is this. HOW could we even start to pay for a private home health aide,or a nursing home? its a catch 22. We this week at the end of the month have trouble coming up with gas money to and from his facility so how could we start to pay

      continued.

    21. Reached 40,000 signatures
    22. Decision-maker Kathleen Fogarty responds:

      Kathleen Fogarty

      Ms. March - I appreciate your concern for your father and am sorry he is ill. Our Health Administration Service has several options you can take to try and resolve this matter and is attempting to contact you to advise you about the steps...


    23. Reached 10,000 signatures
    24. Thank you

      Nicole March
      Petition Organiser

      MY mother and I want to say thank you to everyone who has signed. We never ever expected this response and as it seems to keep steaming ahead we are shocked really shocked. As I am relatively new to FL (we are from NY originally) I doubted I could get half of everyone I know on facebook to sign let alone this. If we could say thank you to each of you personally we would. Thanks again for this. This week ill be attempting to contact various outlets and hopefully with some of power this petition has I hope I can garner some interest.

      thanks

    25. Reached 9,000 signatures

    Supporters

    Reasons for signing

    • Victory Angelite BELLE PLAINE, KS
      • 22 days ago

      Okay, there is something totally wrong with this system in our society. If you like America and being Free due to our Soldiers fight for our Freedom here in America. Yet, you want to disrespect them by not giving them proper housing, medical help, food, and clothing. This is a form of discrimination besides being totally disrespectful and rude towards our American Veterans! All Veterans should get proper care and support from all of us! My grandfather Stanley used to fight in the Korean War too! And if he was alive today, I expect the government and citizens besides my family to give the out most respect, support and care for him too! God Bless Our Veterans!

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:
    • Stephen Van Osdell MAINEVILLE, OH
      • about 1 month ago

      All WWII Vets should receive a much higher standard of health services than they are getting.

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:
    • Sherry Larson EL PASO, TX
      • about 1 month ago

      He is a veteran he has earned this support. It is a shame on our nation to see this happen to this man.

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:
    • Sean. Kelly JUNCTION CITY, KS
      • about 1 month ago

      I am a Retired Army Veteran, 100% total and permanent service connected disabled thru the VA. I sure hope you guys and the VA finds his records to provide him services. It's sad they make us do all the "leg work" to provide documents they should be finding for us.

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:
    • Gregory Duncan WASHINGTON, DC
      • about 1 month ago

      I am so sorry for your loss and his mistreatment. I know first hand their lack of help. took me 20 years to even be seen for an issue I got in the NAVY. I am bringing the fight for help up one by one if I have to.

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:

    Develop your own tools to win.

    Use the Change.org API to develop your own organising tools. Find out how to get started.