Stop the Harming and Killing of Animals in Florida Classrooms
  • Petitioned Eric J. Smith

This petition was delivered to:

Commissioner of Department of Education
Eric J. Smith
Superintendent of Schools
W. Daniel Boyd, Jr.
Hawthorne Middle/High School Principal
Veita Jackson-Carter
Alachua County Public Schools

Stop the Harming and Killing of Animals in Florida Classrooms

    1. Petition by


On April 15, 2009, two students at Hawthorne High School, in Alachua County, Florida outside Gainesville, bashed a live chicken to the ground, videotaped the episode, and posted it on the Internet. Meanwhile, students inside the school tortured chickens to death in an orgy of classroom cruelty, including decapitation and neck “popping,” under the eye of Future Farmers of America teacher, Allen Shaw. The YouTube video shows Robert Gordon bashing a chicken, while Patrick Dougan says “Rip him apart” and “This is animal cruelty.” They laugh as the chicken flops to death on the ground. Though Dougan and Gordon were arrested and charged with animal cruelty, the charges were reluctantly dropped by the State Attorney’s Office on technicalities. The YouTube video that sparked the law enforcement investigation can be seen at

Fueled by this episode, UPC president Karen Davis and executive director of Humane Educators Reaching Out (HERO), Susan Hargreaves, filed a Petition for Agency Action with the Florida Department of Education seeking “promulgation of new or clarified rules for humane treatment of animals and banning animal slaughter in K-12 classrooms pursuant to the statutory mandates of Florida education law.” The  Petition hopes to end animal abuse in Florida schools and foster compassion and respect to all living creatures.

Excerpt from the Petition: “The orgy of cruelty in Allen Shaw’s class led directly to the torture of a living creature outside the classroom. Instead of learning to be kind to animals, students were taught to be cruel. This is not what students should be learning from their teachers.” The Petition in its entirety can be read at

What Can I Do?

Sign this Petition to send a message in support of ending killing and cruelty in the classroom.

You can also write letters to the addresses below.

Urge Florida officials in charge of public schools to implement Florida’s humane education laws and prohibit the harming and killing of animals in Florida classrooms. Implore them to ensure that no situation akin to the animal cruelty and butchery conducted at Hawthorne High School takes place again in a Florida school. Request a written reply to your concerns.

Commissioner of Department of Education

Office of the Commissioner

Turlington Bldg., Suite 1514

325 West Gaines Street

Tallahassee, FL 32399

Phone: 850-245-0505

Fax: 850-245-9667




Superintendent of Schools

Alachua County Public Schools

620 E. University Avenue

Gainesville, FL 32601

Phone: 352-955-7300

Email: &



Hawthorne Middle/High School Principal

Hawthorne High School

21403 SE 69th Avenue

Hawthorne, FL 32640

Phone: 352-481-1900

Fax: 352-481-4859



Recent signatures


    1. Reached 6,000 signatures
    2. Chicken-Bashing Video Prompts Petition to End Classroom Slaughter

      In 2009, a video surfaced of high school student Robert Gordon slamming a live chicken against the ground, while his buddy Patrick Dougan cheered him on with "Rip him apart" and "This is animal cruelty." Where would these teens get the idea to kill a...

    3. Reached 100 signatures


    Reasons for signing

    • yolanda figueroa TAMPA, FL
      • about 2 years ago

      This is so terrible teaching children to be insensitive to the lives of animals....what will they learn at our expense!!!

    • Toni Benteau EDMONTON, CANADA
      • about 2 years ago

      This is numbing ,Im speechless

    • Samantha Perry ST CLAIR, AUSTRALIA
      • about 2 years ago

      It is unnecessary and cruel! Animal abuse is inhumane and needs to be addressed globally! We need to be their voice!

    • Wilma Buchanan-Alliston STEVENAGE, UNITED KINGDOM
      • about 2 years ago

      It is murder of one sentient being by another. In a 'civilised' society, defenseless animals should be protected by humans not tortured and murdered by them. What happened there was cruel, barbaric and unnecessary!

    • Cristina Coll CORAL GABLES, FL
      • about 2 years ago

      Cristina Coll


    Develop your own tools to win.

    Use the API to develop your own organizing tools. Find out how to get started.