Smithtown School District's Board of Education: Allow All Saint James Children to Attend Nesaquake Middle School
  • Petitioned Smithtown School District's Board of Education

This petition was delivered to:

Smithtown School District's Board of Education

Smithtown School District's Board of Education: Allow All Saint James Children to Attend Nesaquake Middle School

    1. Petition by

      Saint James Residents for the Children of Our CommUNITY

In February 2012, Smithtown Central School District's Board of Education responded to a Citizens Advisory Committee's recommendation and voted to close an elementary school. In June 2012, the District closed Nesconset Elementary School. Subsequently, 100% of Nesconset Elementary students were moved/redistricted to Mills Pond Elementary School and 60% of Mills Pond students were redistricted to Saint James Elementary School. The remaining 40% of original Mills Pond Elementary students reside in southeast Saint James, the area south of Woodlawn Avenue between Lake Avenue and Moriches Road.
Historically, upon graduation, all Mills Pond Elementary students transitioned to Nesaquake Middle School, along with students from Saint James Elementary and Dogwood Elementary schools. However, with the close of Nesconset Elementary School, Smithtown Central School District has decided to redistrict all students attending Mills Pond Elementary to Great Hollow Middle School in Nesconset, south of Route 347, effective September 2015.
This decision was made without apparent research or recommendations from "an administrative transition team" that was recommended by the Citizen's Advisory Committee's (January 2012) report to "study middle school moving up patterns" to determine new enrollment boundaries.
As a result of this unilateral decision, approximately 30 students per year who live in southeast Saint James, will attend Great Hollow Middle School in Nesconset, a school of greater than 1000 students.
The parents of these redistricted southeast Saint James students have not been given a choice as has been afforded the parents of students in Saint James Elementary as they prepare for redistricting. As a result, this small group of southeast Saint James students will be separated from students in their home community of Saint James until high school - 9th grade - not middle school as was originally expected. Nesaquake Middle School is not at capacity and has the room to accept these approx. 30 students per year.
Besides the obvious separation from school peers in their community until high school, there are other consequences for this small group of children:
* Interscholastic athletics begin in 7th grade. These students will be deprived the opportunity to begin school team sports with children from their home community.
* Religion classes and Scout troops are arranged according to school boundary lines, which will result in this small group of Saint James children being assigned to predominantly Nesconset groups.
* Performing groups such as band, orchestra, cheer and kickline will perform at Nesconset events whereas Nesaquake groups will perform at Saint James events.
While we understand that Smithtown School District has a responsibility to balance numbers in schools and foster school communities, we also feel very strongly that the District has a responsibility to support parent and student connections with their home communities as well. Keeping, on average, 30 students per year separated from students in their home community of Saint James until high school is not a responsible decision.
We parents also recognize that, by sending this small group of students to Nesaquake each year, the graduating classes of Mills Pond Elementary will be split between middle schools; however, we would like to point out that the split will only occur during middle school and that these students will be reunited with their Nesconset friends 3 years later in Smithtown High School East, which we feel is a positive outcome for all of the children involved. Please keep all of Saint James students together in Nesaquake Middle School. If you support this petition, please sign and share it with others in our community who would like to support our children as well. Thank you.

Recent signatures

    News

    1. Reached 500 signatures

    Supporters

    Reasons for signing

    • Kim Quinn SAINT JAMES, NY
      • over 1 year ago

      All three of my kids went to preschool in St. James and attend Mills Pond and are looking forward to going to Nesaquake to meet up the the kids they know from St. James Elem.

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:
    • Judd Taylor LOS ANGELES, CA
      • over 1 year ago

      To:

      Smithtown School District's Board of Education

      Please listen to these parents and community members of Saint James and allow all St. James children, including those living in southeast Saint James, to attend Nesaquake Middle School. We believe that children need to make connections with peers in their home community long before their freshman year of high school. We also feel strongly that redistricting, on average, 30 children per year from one community to a middle school with more than 1000 students outside of their home community is absolutely not in the best interest of our children. While we understand that sending this small group of students to Nesaquake would split the graduating classes of Mills Pond Elementary between two middle schools, the fact that all of these children will meet up again in high school 3 years later is a positive outcome for all of the children involved. Please unite the children of Saint James at the middle school level in Nesaquake.

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:
    • Jennine Cullen ST JAMES, NY
      • over 1 year ago

      I bought this house with the idea that my daughter would go to St James schools. Now she is 3 and I can't believe she is going to be bussed so far away! I want my daughter to be a part of the St James tradition that I have been a part of for 35 years!

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:
    • Theresa Mangione SMITHTOWN, NY
      • over 1 year ago

      i care about the children in this community

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:
    • Joseph DeNicola ST. JAMES, NY
      • over 1 year ago

      This decision will have a significant impact on my family. If my youngest daughter, currently a third grader at Mills Pond, is not permitted to attend Nesaquake, she will be in a different middle school then her older sister.

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:

    Develop your own tools to win.

    Use the Change.org API to develop your own organizing tools. Find out how to get started.