• Petitioned Please forward to CEO/ President

This petition was delivered to:

Auto Loans Department
Please forward to CEO/ President
Business Services
Please forward to CEO/President
Marketing Department
Please forward to CEO/President
Human Resources
Please forward to CEO/President

Return Robert's Truck

    1. Mary Roberts
    2. Petition by

      Mary Roberts

      slatington, PA

This is a story that I would like to tell you about a local firefighter that responded to a call in December of 2012. During this call a woman was trapped in her car, while it was on fire, with no way out. The firemen did all that they could, but there was no way of saving her; they watched her burn to death.

This took a toll on all of the firefighters. My son was one of them. He had a hard time dealing with this situation because he knew the woman and, despite all of his training, he could not help her. My son always would have helped anyone that needed help. About two weeks later, on Christmas Eve, my son took his own life before he could get help. Counseling had been offered for the fire fighters, but for Robert, it was too late.

In his passing, I was left with the task of paying for all of the funeral expenses. But first, I called First Commonwealth Federal Credit Union to inform them of his death, because he had his truck loan with them. At that time they told me that all I had to do was provide them with a certificate of death, a few other pieces of paperwork, and the loan would be forgiven.

At that time this meant that I could give my son a full fireman's funeral, which I would have not been able to afford otherwise. We went ahead with the funeral, counting on the money we were going to save by not having to continue on the truck payments, to pay for the services.

One week after the funeral I went to the Credit Union with the paperwork that they said I needed to bring to them. When the bank pulled up his loan they said that they had made a mistake, that the loan now would not be forgiven. I had them pull up the email that the person sent me, who told me the truck payments would be forgiven. They did this and found that I was correct, she had told me that I could keep my son's truck and the remaining payments would be written off.

After spending all this money on the funeral, it put me in a bind, and so I asked the bank to honor their promise to me. They said that they could not do this, so I was left with no choice but to get a lawyer. I was lucky enough to be offered free legal services from a new attorney who had also been friends with my son. This attorney did some legal research and found that my case fell under a legal theory known as “promissory estoppel."

Under promissory estoppel, Pennsylvania courts will enforce a promise made by one party if certain criteria
are met::

1. A promise must have been made
2. It was reasonable or foreseeable for the other party to rely on this promise
3. The other party (in reliance of this promise) took action or refrained from taking action and
4. injustice can only be prevented by enforcing the promise.

My case met all the requirements. So, my attorney started writing letters to the attorney representing the Credit Union.
My lawyer requested a transcript of the phone call. It then took about seven weeks for them to get back to us with it. My attorney forwarded information from the funeral home showing proof of the expenses incurred.

After months of back and forth letter writing, the best offer the Credit Union gave to me was to keep the truck and keep paying on it with zero percent interest. I refused this offer, since I was not in a financial position to make expensive monthly truck payments after having relied on their promise to me.

Then, with no notice, on July 14th, 2013 the truck was repossessed. In a way, it was like losing Robert all over again. This truck, to my family, is so much more than just a vehicle. It feels like it is the last tangible thing we have left of Robert. This truck carries so much sentimental value that I feel like it is irreplaceable. I feel like only someone who has lost a loved one could understand the value that this vehicle has to me and my wife.

My lawyer is still working on the case and at no cost to us. But, she is one new attorney with limited experience, up against a large bank that is represented by one of the largest law firms in Eastern Pennsylvania.

I am telling this to you in hope that this story will show the people of the Lehigh Valley what kind of institution First Commonwealth really is. I also hope that after reading this you will help us to get Robert's truck back. A financial institution should not be able to lie to a person, especially in a time of unimaginable grief. They should not be able to do anything that they wish; they should not be above the law.

Please help us. YOU could sign this petition to First Commonwealth expressing your support for my cause and asking them to honor their original promise and to RETURN ROBERT'S TRUCK. Please sign and share this cause. If you wish to contact First Commonwealth Federal Credit Union by letter with the hope of helping us,  address any letters to:

First Commonwealth Federal Credit Union
P. O. Box 20450
Lehigh Valley, PA 18002-0450

Also, any additional legal help would be greatly appreciated.

Thank you for taking the time to read this.

Michael Best
Phone: 610-767-1129
Email: bulldog1342p@verizon.net

Update 08/03/2013: Since the truck was available to be sold by First Commonwealth Credit Union anytime after July 30th, the family went ahead and got the vehicle refinanced through their personal bank so that the truck could once again be in the family's possession. **HOWEVER, the fight is NOT OVER. The Best Family still has every intention of filing a lawsuit to be reimbursed for their losses and to hold the Credit Union responsible... so please keep sharing the story and signing the petition. Thanks!!
To:
Please forward to CEO/ President, Auto Loans Department
Please forward to CEO/President, Business Services
Please forward to CEO/President, Marketing Department
Please forward to CEO/President, Human Resources
Return Robert's Truck

Sincerely,
[Your name]

Recent signatures

    News

    1. Reached 6,000 signatures

    Supporters

    Reasons for signing

    • Justin Moate AUSTIN, PA
      • 5 months ago

      Robert and the Entire Best family are very dear to my family and I, Robert worked extremely hard for everything he had in his life and took special pride in his truck and all his possessions. The institution made a promise that the debt would be forgiven and it needs to hold this promise, The best family lost something that could never be replaced, the least they could have is the one thing Robert loved so dearly!

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:
    • george herold EDINBURGH, UNITED KINGDOM
      • 8 months ago

      always the dollar

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:
    • Donna McKee LEDERACH, PA
      • 8 months ago

      Honor your promise to this man. Does your word mean nothing? If so, then your reputation will mean nothing, either.

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:
    • mike wilkinson SEATTLE, WA, WA
      • 10 months ago

      the bank screwed up on this one ...I hope the family ruins the reputation of this institution....and I am sorry for your loss....

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:
    • David Merritt CULLMAN, AL
      • 11 months ago

      Heartless Credit Union honor your promise to forgive the debt.

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:

    Develop your own tools to win.

    Use the Change.org API to develop your own organizing tools. Find out how to get started.