• Petitioning Security Team at Westfield Plaze Mall in Carlsbad, CA

This petition will be delivered to:

Security Team at Westfield Plaze Mall in Carlsbad, CA
District General Manager at Westfield
Becky Smith

Issue a public apology to Lisa Vaca, Sandra Deakins, Kim Keeline, Colleen Kelly Burks, and company for the treatment they received from mall security on February 9, 2014.

    1. Petition by

      Adrie Marcellus

      Kennewick, WA

Recently, a group of Steampunk affeciandos, visited the Westfield Plaza Mall in Carlsbad CA. On their way to the mall's carousel they were accosted by the mall security and told they had to leave per the Mall's "Code of Conduct Policy." Please read the following article as reported by Marcy Baron of the San Diego Reader for more information.

"Over 40 people in steampunk garb (Victorian dress meets sci-fi/time traveler) were turned away from the Westfield Plaza Mall in Carlsbad on February 9 — mall security told them to leave because they were breaking the mall’s “code of conduct.”

The code states that “wearing apparel that disguises, obscures or conceals the face” is not allowed.

Lisa Vaca, one of those costumed, stated, “Since none of us had any part of our faces obscured, we respectfully pointed it out to the three security guards, and then their new reason for asking us to leave was a mix of ‘this is private property so we can refuse entrance to anyone,’ and ‘a group of this number needs to call ahead first to get permission,’ and, our favorite, ‘recently we had a big problem with a vampire group who showed up here….’

Vaca further went on to state, “When they told us to leave, they didn't even give us the option to ‘Please remove your hats and other costume-type items if you want to stay.’ They just walked up to a couple of our wonderfully dressed women and said, ‘You have to leave!’”

Vaca told security that this same group went to the carousel at the Westfield Mall in El Cajon a few months ago and was welcomed with open arms.

Sandra Deakins, another steampunk participant, said she felt “corralled” and given the “ushering effect.” As they streamed out of the mall, the group was greeted by three Oceanside police patrol cars and three police officers.

“The police told us that they were just answering a call from mall security and wanted to make sure the group was nice folks,” said Vaca.

Steampunk Kim Keeline said, “We were told it was to keep out the riffraff. In various conversations with the security and the police, this was variously described as gangs, people in vampire costumes, a group that tried to come ride the carousel last week while wearing horsehead masks, and other such riffraff."

Others told me that security in golf carts followed some of the participants to their cars. The mall likely lost a lot of potential shoppers that day, as many said they had planned to do some store browsing after riding the carousel. Some told me that they will never return to this mall to shop.

When I called mall security to get a statement on February 10, the person on the other end of the phone told me they weren’t allowed to comment on the incident.

When I called mall management, I spoke to their operations manager, who asked to remain anonymous. When he said, “It was probably a misunderstanding. All Westfield Malls have the same code of conduct policy.”

I then told him this same group had no problem at the El Cajon Westfield Mall. He said, “No comment,” and wouldn’t answer any more questions. He told me to call the next day and speak to their district general manager, which I did.

District general manager Becky Smith couldn’t or wouldn’t come to the phone: her secretary said she was either in meetings or conference calls after I tried three times to reach her."

What the mall security fails to realize, is that Victorian and Edwardian apparel is gaining popularity as regular, every day attire for folks. People that do not participate in the Steampunk culture wear such clothing daily. This policy, as enforced by Westfield Plaza's security team, leaves room for further discrimination down the line. These folks were not harming anyone, nor were they breaking the rules of conduct and they deserve an apology as well as the security team receiving training as to what counts as an infraction of the policy.

To:
Security Team at Westfield Plaze Mall in Carlsbad, CA
Becky Smith, District General Manager at Westfield
Issue a public apology to Lisa Vaca, Sandra Deakins, Kim Keeline, Colleen Kelly Burks, and company for the treatment they received from mall security on February 9, 2014.

Sincerely,
[Your name]

Recent signatures

    News

    1. Reached 250 signatures

    Supporters

    Reasons for signing

    • Tim Boothby MOUNTAIN HOME, ID
      • 4 months ago

      I've photographed people in steampunk attire in a state capitol building and all security did there was take pictures with their phones and admire the costumes. Obviously these were professionals and not minimum wage mall mounties.

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:
    • Randall Burr LORAIN, OH
      • 5 months ago

      I'm am a costumer, renfaire & convention goer. This treatment was appalling & can NOT be tolerated in a civilized society.

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:
    • Cecile Fleetwood SAN DIEGO, CA
      • 7 months ago

      They weren't disruptive. They were more covered than most teenagers these day! I do not understand the problem! The Steam Punk group were discriminated against because they looked different! Apologies & open minds are the least of my expectations!

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:
    • Broderick Blocker TUCSON, AZ
      • 8 months ago

      Mall security was wrong. Period. Own up, apologize, and learn from it.

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:
    • Mary Sturhann SAN DIEGO, CA
      • 8 months ago

      I am an adult costumer and often wear Steampunk outfits. I've never had a problem before. Also, most Steampunks do not wear masks so the Malls reason is invalid! The Mall is in the wrong and should apologize already.

      REPORT THIS COMMENT:

    Develop your own tools to win.

    Use the Change.org API to develop your own organizing tools. Find out how to get started.