Not quite fair to say that Rory Stewart is a "dove progressive." He is running for parliament in the UK as a conservative:
http://www.tnr.com/article/world/the-t%E2%80%85e-lawrence-afghanistan?page=0,1
Clever blog post, but fantastically bad career advice.
Alanna's conflates bad jobs and bad organizations. Bad jobs are the necessary steps one needs to take in order to gain experience and move on to more compelling work in the future. Within the international aid work, most jobs involving 'backstopping' of overseas projects can fall into this category. The work is dreary, but it provides an entry point to more substantive opportunities down the road.
Bad organizations, on the other hand, are dysfunctional or disreputable groups that have no business staying in business. At best, they waste resources and reinforce the sorry reputation of non-profits as inefficient. At worst, they 'do harm' in the field. Many of them have a tendency to mistreat, dis-empower, and take shameful advantage of their junior staff. Do bright young lawyers and doctors seek out bad law firms and hospitals bad institutions, as proof that they understand the profession and won't freak out in the courthouse or operating room? Hell no. As aid slowly grows into a profession, we need to develop institutions and incentive structures that either encourage organizations to invest in their staff, or drive them out of business altogether.
|
3 Actions
|