I couldn't agree more, and you articulated many of the frustrations I had as a recent college student watching so many well-intentioned organizations ship well-intentioned, yet unskilled and inexperienced, volunteers across the country and around the world to do jobs that locals could have benefitted from doing. A recent experience I had volunteering in Honduras epitomizes this point. I went there, not really knowing what I was getting myself into, as part of a team to help rural villages improve their access to clean water. To make a long and sad story short, the sponsoring organization's method of "empowering" villages to create "sustainable" water systems (their language), was to send in a bunch of rich, non-Spanish speaking white kids to do what the Honduran villagers could have done 10 times better and faster. I told my project leader at the end of the week that I would have rather given the money I paid to get to Honduras directly to the villagers as wages for doing the work themselves.