Tell Carson Valley Middle School to Respect Its Students' Rights

Tell Carson Valley Middle School to Respect Its Students' Rights

The Issue

Carson Valley Middle School just suspended a dozen 9th graders because of marijuana -- not because they were smoking it, but because they were advocating the legalization of it.

According to the Associated Press, students at the Nevada school hung more than two dozen signs calling for the legalization of pot and for authorities to “free” three of their classmates who had apparently been taken into custody for “suspicion of smoking marijuana.”

A valuable example of free speech in action -- a teachable moment, perhaps? Not to school principal Robert Been. "What they did is not a cool thing to do. It just stirs up the campus," he told the Associated Press. "It's not conducive to our education environment. This is a school for crying out loud."

Indeed, it is a school, a place of learning where freedom of thought and expression are supposed to be encouraged … right? That’s what the ACLU of Nevada thinks, charging that the students weren’t suspended for what they did -- hang a few posters -- but for what they said.

School administrators should be nurturing peaceful, free expression, not suppressing it. Tell Principal Been and his boss, Superintendent Lisa Noonan, to state, for the record, that from now on they will support the right of students to exercise their freedom of speech -- and that they regret the decision to suspend young Americans simply for exercising that right.

Photo Credit: Carson Valley Middle School

avatar of the starter
Charles DavisPetition StarterCharles has reported on topics from the war on drugs to the war on terror, his having aired on NPR and Pacifica stations across the country and been published by outlets including <i>AlterNet</i>, <a href="http://Antiwar.com" rel="nofollow">Antiwar.com</a>, <a href="http://CommonDreams.org" rel="nofollow">CommonDreams.org</a>, <i>Counterpunch</i> and Inter Press Service. He has also enjoyed stints working as a researcher on Michael Moore’s <i>Capitalism: A Love Story</i>, waiting tables at a surprisingly seedy Friendly’s family restaurant (several stints, actually), and mixing and packaging horseradish-based products at a small factory in Pennsylvania. He did not particularly enjoy that last one.
This petition had 362 supporters

The Issue

Carson Valley Middle School just suspended a dozen 9th graders because of marijuana -- not because they were smoking it, but because they were advocating the legalization of it.

According to the Associated Press, students at the Nevada school hung more than two dozen signs calling for the legalization of pot and for authorities to “free” three of their classmates who had apparently been taken into custody for “suspicion of smoking marijuana.”

A valuable example of free speech in action -- a teachable moment, perhaps? Not to school principal Robert Been. "What they did is not a cool thing to do. It just stirs up the campus," he told the Associated Press. "It's not conducive to our education environment. This is a school for crying out loud."

Indeed, it is a school, a place of learning where freedom of thought and expression are supposed to be encouraged … right? That’s what the ACLU of Nevada thinks, charging that the students weren’t suspended for what they did -- hang a few posters -- but for what they said.

School administrators should be nurturing peaceful, free expression, not suppressing it. Tell Principal Been and his boss, Superintendent Lisa Noonan, to state, for the record, that from now on they will support the right of students to exercise their freedom of speech -- and that they regret the decision to suspend young Americans simply for exercising that right.

Photo Credit: Carson Valley Middle School

avatar of the starter
Charles DavisPetition StarterCharles has reported on topics from the war on drugs to the war on terror, his having aired on NPR and Pacifica stations across the country and been published by outlets including <i>AlterNet</i>, <a href="http://Antiwar.com" rel="nofollow">Antiwar.com</a>, <a href="http://CommonDreams.org" rel="nofollow">CommonDreams.org</a>, <i>Counterpunch</i> and Inter Press Service. He has also enjoyed stints working as a researcher on Michael Moore’s <i>Capitalism: A Love Story</i>, waiting tables at a surprisingly seedy Friendly’s family restaurant (several stints, actually), and mixing and packaging horseradish-based products at a small factory in Pennsylvania. He did not particularly enjoy that last one.

The Decision Makers

Robert Been
Robert Been
Principal
Lisa Noonan
Lisa Noonan
Superintendent

Petition Updates